The pageant of Parliament, vol. 1 of 2MacDonagh, Michael
History
The pageant of Parliament, vol. 1 of 2
MacDonagh, Michael
Great Britain. Parliament
But suppose a Speaker, who, of course, puts his own interpretation
on precedents and Standing Orders, ultimately finds that he has made
a wrong ruling, what ought he to do in the way of rectifying it?
Thomas Moore relates in his _Diary_ an extraordinary discussion on
this point with Manners-Sutton after dinner one evening in 1829 at
the Speaker’s house. “Dwelt much on the advantages of humbug,” writes
Moore, in reference to Manners-Sutton; “of a man knowing how to take
care of his reputation, and to keep from being _found out_, so as
always to pass for cleverer than he is.” Moore says he himself argued
that this denoted a wise man, not a humbug. If by that line of policy
a man induced his fellow-men to give him credit for being cleverer
than he really was, the fault could not be his, so long as he did not
himself advance any claim to it as his due. The moment he _pretended_
to be what he was not, then began humbug, but not sooner. The poet
then goes on:
He still pushed his point, playfully, but pertinaciously, and in
illustration of what he meant put the following case: “Suppose
a Speaker rather new to his office, and a question brought into
discussion before him which Parties are equally divided upon,
and which he sees will run to very inconvenient lengths if not
instantly decided. Well, though ignorant entirely on the subject,
he assumes an air of authority, and gives his decision, which sets
the matter at rest. On going home he finds that he has decided
quite wrongly; and then, without making any further fuss about the
business, he quietly goes and _alters_ the _entry_ on the Journals.”
Moore again insisted that wisdom, and not humbug, was the
characteristic of such an action. “To his _supposed_ case all I had
to answer,” the poet writes, “was that I still thought the man a
wise one, and no humbug; by his resolution in a moment of difficulty
he prevented a _present_ mischief, and by his withdrawal of a wrong
precedent averted a _future_ one.”
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account