The pageant of Parliament, vol. 1 of 2MacDonagh, Michael
History
The pageant of Parliament, vol. 1 of 2
MacDonagh, Michael
Great Britain. Parliament
In view of the common interests of the country and its complete
coherence in social and economic life, it would be idle to limit
the electors in their choice of representatives to local residents.
Moreover, such a restriction would tend to the exclusion from
Parliament of able and distinguished men whose reputation is national
rather than local. But one regrettable result of this freedom of
selection is that the varying idiosyncrasies of the different parts
of the country are no longer reflected, distinctly and sharply, in
the House of Commons. The representatives are not, in many cases,
racy of the soil of their constituencies. Each of them is not
permeated with the spirit of the place for which he sits—thinking
its local thought, speaking its dialect, having its accent on his
tongue. A man with an Irish brogue may sit for a London constituency.
A South of England man may represent the northernmost constituency
in Scotland. This typical Yorkshireman finds a seat in the West
of England; that unmistakable Devon man speaks for a place in
Lancashire. The manufacturer is returned by an agricultural county;
the country squire by an industrial borough. It is true that in
the main the representatives of Wales and Scotland are essentially
Welsh and Scottish, though less so with respect to Scotland than
with respect to the other Celtic fringe. The English membership,
which constitutes the vast bulk of the House, is also strong in
English characteristics; but the views, feelings and interests of a
particular locality are seldom expressed in its voice and with its
manner by its representative. Though a local man is still supposed to
be, more or less, a strong candidate, in truth local representation
in Parliament is fast losing its local character and ceasing to
have any local purpose at all under the operation of the Caucus,
or the system of rigidly organized political Parties. Members of
Parliament are no longer chosen specially to safeguard the local
interests of their constituencies. Their chief purpose is to have the
country governed and administered by the light of their political
principles. This Member is said to sit for Hodgeshire, that other
for Cottonopolis. What they really represent, generally speaking, is
the Conservative Central Office, or the Liberal Central Office, or
the Labour Executive. But while membership of the House of Commons
is now thoroughly political, it is, for that very reason, also
thoroughly national. “Every Member, though chosen by one particular
district, when elected and returned serves for the whole Realm.” So
wrote Blackstone, in his _Commentaries on the Laws of England_, about
the middle of the eighteenth century. It was, then, perhaps, but a
pious aspiration. It is now undoubtedly an accomplished fact, at
least in the sense that the representative serves for the whole Realm
according to the political principles which he is returned to uphold.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account