After they come out the difference of life and work is still greater.
In the old days, for instance, they picked up the language quickly and
well. The time to learn a language is when you are young--the younger
the better. We learn our own language as children. The older we grow
the harder it is, because it means not merely learning by heart a great
many words, not merely training the palate and tongue to produce
different sounds, but adopting a new attitude of mind. Nothing
definite has been discovered as to the localisation of faculties in the
brain, therefore nothing certain is known; but it has always seemed to
me and to others whom I have consulted that when you learn a new
language you are exercising and developing a new piece of brain. When
you know several languages and change from one to another you seem
definitely to change the piece of brain which actuates your tongue.
You switch off one centre and switch on to another. You will always
notice in yourself and others that there is a definite pause when the
change of language is made. Now it becomes every year more difficult
to awaken an unused part of the brain and bring it into active use, and
to begin at twenty-three is late. True, languages are taught them at
Oxford before they come out, but the result seems _nil_. You must
learn a language where it is spoken. Moreover, the way they have been
taught Latin and Greek is a hindrance, for living languages are not
learnt that way. A child, for instance, learns to talk perfectly
without ever learning grammar. I never heard that any great English
writer had a grounding in English grammar. There is no real grammar of
a living language, because it grows and changes. You can only have a
fixed grammar of a dead language.
The fact is that correct talking is the outcome of correct thinking,
not of any mechanical rules. You must think in a language before you
can speak it well.
But at twenty-three it is far too late for the ordinary man to learn to
think in Hindustani or Burmese or Tamil. Of course there are
occasional exceptions, but the way these languages are usually spoken
is dreadful. I could tell tales about myself as well as others, for
though I worked very hard for years I never knew Burmese well, nor yet
Canarese, nor yet Hindustani. Yet who will doubt that it is very
important, the most important acquisition, in fact, that you can make?
Without it you can never really get near the people. So that in this
way the old civilian had again a great advantage.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account