During the cold weather he should be with some District Officer,
accompanying him in camp, observing how he works, getting an insight
into the mechanism of Government; during the hot weather he should be
in the hills. By thus keeping him out of the great heat at the
beginning he would become slowly acclimatised. Now he is plunged
straight out from England into the Indian plains.
As to the training he should receive, that is not very difficult to
suggest. First and foremost comes the language, of which a good
colloquial knowledge should be required. It can only be acquired by
talking to the people. A teacher is useful to explain difficulties
encountered by a pupil in trying to talk, but no teacher can teach a
language. In fact, languages cannot be taught--they can be acquired.
The ability of the ear and vocal organs to recognise and reproduce
strange sounds comes only with constant practice; and it must be
practice with the people, for educated men talk differently from
peasants in India as elsewhere. All Acts should be learned by first
clearly understanding the principles that underlie them, the object
sought to attain, and the method by which it is hoped to attain it.
That is the only way to really understand an Act or Code. The detailed
knowledge can be filled in later. In order to enable this to be done
Government would have to frame introductions to their Codes and Acts.
And such introductions would be most valuable not only to learners but
to Government itself. Suppose, for instance, an introduction were
written to the _Village Manual_ explaining exactly what the village
organism is and that the Act and Rules were intended to preserve and
strengthen this organism; it would be immediately apparent that as they
are now they really injure and destroy it. This would lead to a
complete recast of the _Manual_--a most necessary work. And so with
the other Acts and Rules. Now they are issued in a perfectly naked
state that would be almost immodest had they any real life in them.
But there is never any intention or life manifest, only dead formulæ.
Such introductions would also be most valuable in keeping an Act up to
date. A law may fairly fulfil its intention when issued, but as
circumstances change it would become obvious that the Act was out of
date. If however you don't know the intention of the Act, how are you
to judge its relevancy?
Further, such introductions would prevent the abuse of certain
sections. Did, for instance, the Government of India intend sections
109, 110, of the Criminal Procedure Code to be used as they are in
Burma now? I doubt it. But Burma can always say: "How was I to know
the intention? There are the sections. Why shouldn't I use them as I
think fit?"
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account