The Peace Negotiations: A Personal NarrativeLansing, Robert
History
The Peace Negotiations: A Personal Narrative
Lansing, Robert
League of Nations; Paris Peace Conference (1919-1920); Wilson, Woodrow, 1856-1924
"The legal principle [of the equality of nations], whatever its basis
in fact, must be preserved, otherwise force rather than law, the
power to act rather than the right to act, becomes the fundamental
principle of organization, just as it has been in all previous
Congresses and Concerts of the European Powers.
"It appears to me that a positive guaranty of territorial integrity
and political independence by the nations would have to rest upon an
open recognition of dominant coercive power in the articles of
agreement, the power being commercial and economic as well as
physical. The wisdom of entering into such a guaranty is questionable
and should be carefully considered before being adopted.
"In order to avoid the recognition of force as a basis and the
question of dominant force with the unavoidable classification of
nations into 'big' and 'little,' 'strong' and 'weak,' the desired
result of a guaranty might be attained by entering into a mutual
undertaking _not_ to impair the territorial integrity or to violate
the political sovereignty of any state. The breach of this
undertaking would be a breach of the treaty and would sever the
relations of the offending nation with all other signatories."
I have given these two extracts from my notes in order to show the views
that I held, at the time the American Commission was about to depart
from the United States, in regard to the character of the guaranty which
the President intended to make the central feature of the League of
Nations. In the carrying out of his scheme and in creating an
organization to give effect to the guaranty I believed that I saw as an
unavoidable consequence an exaltation of force and an overlordship of
the strong nations. Under such conditions it would be impossible to
preserve within the organization the equality of nations, a precept of
international law which was the universally recognized basis of
intercourse between nations in time of peace. This I considered most
unwise and a return to the old order, from which every one hoped that
the victory over the Central Empires had freed the world.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account