But the obstacle which most effectually blocks the use of Onderdonk's
classification in the systematic arrangement of peaches is the brood
of hybrid seedling peaches annually brought forth by fruit-growers.
No doubt the classification is workable, to a degree, with the
type-varieties and a few carefully selected progeny but after the
practical peach-grower, with a devil-may-care attitude toward
classification, crosses and recrosses the types, the several races
become hopelessly interlocked. The characters chiefly used by
Onderdonk, as has been said, are fluctuating variations and these do
not descend according to Mendelian laws. And so the great out-pouring
of varieties during the past quarter-century has literally swamped
a classification which served only fairly well when it included but
the pioneer varieties. In the trituration of the thousand and more
varieties of peaches now going on, the Onderdonk classification will be
less and less useful.
In dismissing the Onderdonk scheme as having but limited application
for classificatory purposes, acknowledgment is made that it serves
other purposes very well. It calls attention to the history of the
peach; it shows that racial strains of the peach are arising; it brings
out valuable information in regard to hardiness and the rest-period of
peaches; it offers instances of modification of the peach by climate;
and it shows the capacity of the peach to vary. For thus illuminating
the natural history of the peach, more especially the climatology of
the peach, pomology is much indebted to Onderdonk and Price.
_A key to varieties of peaches._--A natural classification of peaches
to show the relationships of varieties is seemingly impossible. The
deluge of new varieties, which growers continue with cheerful optimism
to pour out, overwhelms the classifier with difficulties. About the
best that can be done is to arrange varieties, for convenience in
identifying, according to some of the artificial systems of a century
ago when the cult of the classifier was at its height. These were
really synoptical keys rather than biological classifications. If such
a key is to be used very generally by fruit-growers, only characters of
the fruit are admissible, thereby attaining necessary simplicity and
providing that all data can be had at one examination.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account