The Peak in Darien, With Some Other Inquiries Touching Concerns of the Soul and the Body: An Octave of EssaysCobbe, Frances Power
Religion
The Peak in Darien, With Some Other Inquiries Touching Concerns of the Soul and the Body: An Octave of Essays
Cobbe, Frances Power
Christianity; Death -- Religious aspects -- Christianity; Medicine -- Religious aspects -- Christianity; Women in Christianity
But how is this recognition of the duty and glory of the sacrifice of
health and life at the call of every higher law to be reconciled with
the “Doctor’s Doctrine” that the interests of health are so supreme
that they themselves constitute the highest law, and render any
practice conducive to them _ipso facto_ lawful? Either we must admit,
according to the Divine’s Doctrine, that moral interests transcend
bodily interests, or we must hold, according to Doctor’s Doctrine,
that bodily interests transcend moral interests. There is no third
alternative. One principle or the other must prevail, and sooner or
later leaven society with its ennobling or else its debasing influence.
There are signs apparent that the Doctor’s Doctrine is already bearing
its proper fruit, and that, soothed by a becalmed conscience, absolved
by the authority of the priesthood of Science, men and women are
beginning to be systematically selfish and self-indulgent where their
health is concerned, or where there may appear a chance of curing their
maladies in modes not hitherto witnessed. I can only indicate a few of
the ways in which this deliberate self-preservation is exhibited.
Notably, it seems that the old courage of Englishmen is dwindling away.
Almost every month, cases come to light wherein men, even soldiers,
fail to stand by their comrades in danger; or wherein a crowd of fifty
people witness a child drowning in a shallow pond without an effort to
save it; or men who witness a cruel murder rush from the spot, leaving
the yet breathing victim dying unaided on the ground. There is even,
among young men, a cynical avowal of prudent concern for their own
lives and limbs which constantly strikes the old, who remember the
joyous youthful fearlessness of their fathers, as something altogether
new and far indeed from pleasant to contemplate.
Nor are our personal acts of selfishness and cowardice on a small scale
the only logical consequences of the new principle which are already
visible. Cruelty of the most heinous and systematic kind is another
result. The unanimous resolution passed by the great Medical Congress
in the year of grace 1881 has proclaimed that vivisection leads to
discoveries conducive to the cure of disease, and _therefore_ should
be sanctioned and left unrestricted by law. That is to say, that all
the fiendish imaginations of men like Mantegazza and Schiff, and Goltz
and Bernard, and Paul Bert, should be freely permitted in England for
the sake of a chance of useful hints for therapeutic science. Thus,
the whole medical profession in England stands committed to the demand
that the vice of cruelty in young men and old should be deliberately
unchained, expressly for the sake of anticipated benefits to bodily
health.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account