The Peak in Darien, With Some Other Inquiries Touching Concerns of the Soul and the Body: An Octave of EssaysCobbe, Frances Power
Religion
The Peak in Darien, With Some Other Inquiries Touching Concerns of the Soul and the Body: An Octave of Essays
Cobbe, Frances Power
Christianity; Death -- Religious aspects -- Christianity; Medicine -- Religious aspects -- Christianity; Women in Christianity
Brought up in these common views, probably not one of us modern
Europeans has perused, for the first time, a philosophical statement
of the pessimist principles which underlie the vast religions of the
farther East, without a shock of astonishment. Individually, we may
have found our particular share of existence painful rather than
pleasurable. Disease, poverty, disappointment, bereavement, may have
embittered our years. But that any order of men, outside of lunatic
asylums, should lay down as a postulate, whereon to build religion and
morality, that Life is _per se_ an evil, and that, “whatever we have
been, ’tis something better not to be,” and proceed benevolently to
point out how we may, by much diligence, shake off not only this mortal
coil, but the entire burden of being, and arrive at the consummation
of nonentity,--this is an idea revolutionizing the order of our
conceptions, and as nearly incredible as any assertion dealing with
the vagaries of the human mind may be. Even yet, perhaps, some doubts
may legitimately linger as to whether the Buddhist creed, elsewhere
than in Nepaul (where it certainly does _not_ teach annihilation),
really intends by “Nirvana” to set forth the emptiness, rather than the
plenitude, of being. But that both Brahmin and Buddhist teachers have
systematically dealt with life as an evil rather than as a good, there
is, I apprehend, no question among competent inquirers. Here, then, are
two absolutely contrasted, fundamental conceptions of the totality of
human existence,--the Western, that life is a blessing; the Eastern,
that it is a curse. The European cries,--
“’Tis life, not death, for which we pant,--
More life, and fuller, that we want.”
He “shudders at destruction,” and better endures to face even the
tremendous threat of an eternal hell than to relax the tenacity of
his belief in an immortal consciousness. The Indian, on the contrary,
devoutly hopes that a life (or several lives) of self-abnegation, may
bring him to the bourne whence the traveller leaps into the gulf of
nothingness. Marvellous to add, as climax, there seems more likelihood
that a certain number of highly educated Germans, Frenchmen, and
Englishmen, may learn to sigh for Nirvana than that our missionaries
will induce an equal number of intelligent Singalese, Chinese, or
natives of Siam, to exchange their dreary anticipations for the hope of
heaven.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account