The Pennsylvania Journal of Prison Discipline and Philanthropy (Vol. VIII, No. II, April 1853)Philadelphia Society for Alleviating the Miseries of Public Prisons
Religion
The Pennsylvania Journal of Prison Discipline and Philanthropy (Vol. VIII, No. II, April 1853)
Philadelphia Society for Alleviating the Miseries of Public Prisons
Charities -- Periodicals; Prisons -- Periodicals
The conviction forces itself upon my mind, that, if the numerous
weighty objections already given be correct--this (the separate)
system is not only wrong _per se_, but will soon be deserted by
its remaining followers. For if it be true, when alluding to it in
the least objectionable manner, that this system is only suited to
short sentences, as many of its friends and advocates aver, then,
"to all intents and purposes," it must soon be subject to one of
two consequences; either the penal code of the laws of the land
must be so altered as to suit the demand of the system, or the
system must be so altered as to fully come within the demands of
the law.
As to its facts let the following suffice:
Upon the separate and solitary principle, the prisoner--good,
bad, or indifferent as he may be, surrounded by his _Bible_, and
such other good books as are given him from time to time, remains
all alone in his cell, from the first of January to the last of
December, until his term of imprisonment expires; and is thus
left to his own reflections by day, and by night--unless paid an
occasional visit by some kind officer of the prison, or by the
chaplain. And hence it is, that in too many instances to justify
the means employed, _insanity_ precedes the work of reformation.
Were we to cite but a single passage from the report to include the
logic, the rhetoric, the philosophy, the facts, and the reliability of
the statements in a single view, it would be the following:
Upon my arrival in the city of Boston, Massachusetts, so soon as
I had visited the State prison at Charlestown, and the Boston new
jail, under the guidance of Hon. Louis Dwight, I was convinced
in my own mind that said jail, for the purposes for which it was
designed, was decidedly the _model prison of the age_.
The commissioner was so fortunate as not only to see "the model prison
of the age," but to obtain from the same source "a design of a model
prison for the State of Missouri;" and so comprehensive and clear
were the conceptions of the commissioner upon the view of these model
edifices and plans, that he made up his mind when he "first saw the
design," (and his views remained unchanged after his return,) "that it
has no superior either in the United States or in Europe."
Among the inexplicable mis-statements which we find scattered through
the report, we may cite the following:
As has been proven, beyond all successful contradiction, this
system (the congregate) is not only _more humane_, but it is also
_far less expensive_ than the separate system.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account