close of a game of bridge the cards acquire a particular arrangement
indicative of a very definite plan which was present in the minds of
the players shortly after the game began.
Mechanistic biology would seek to explain this transformation of a
homogeneous system of elements into a heterogeneous and specific
arrangement by the interaction of the elements with each other, and by
the reaction of the environment. But, given a homogeneous arrangement
of elements capable of interacting with each other, then only one final
phase can be supposed to be produced. A mixture of sulphur, carbon
dust, copper and iron filings raised suddenly to a high temperature
will only interact in one way, and the final phase of the system will
depend on the composition of the mixture, on the temperature, and
on the conduction of heat into the mixture in the initial stage of
heating. A mixture of chloroform and water shaken up in a bottle is at
first a “homogeneous” mixture of the particles of the two substances,
but under the influence of gravity the liquids separate from each other
and form two distinct layers, each of which will contain in solution
some of the other liquid. A homogeneous mixture of different substances
therefore becomes a heterogeneous arrangement in the inorganic system,
as in the organic one, but while we can predict the former one we
cannot predict the latter. We can express the result of the combination
of the elements of the inorganic mixture as something that depends
on chemical and physical potentials, but this is quite impossible
in the case of the development of the embryonic system. It is not
only that our knowledge of the developmental process is imperfect:
the distinction between the two processes of differentiation is a
fundamental one. A change in the conditions under which the inorganic
system differentiates leads of necessity to a different final phase,
but a change in the conditions under which the embryo develops need
have no such effect. If some unforeseen occurrence takes place--some
artificial interference with the process of segmentation, which could
never have been experienced in the racial history of the organism--a
_regulation_ by the parts of the embryo occurs, and the final phase of
development may be the same as if no interference had been experienced.
That which is operating in the development of the embryo is something
that is permitting, or suspending, or arranging physico-chemical
reactions.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account