Let us think of the developing embryo merely as an aggregation of
substances contained in an inorganic medium: the segmented frog’s egg
floating on the water at the surface of a pond is an example. As an
inorganic system its fate is determined. Autolysis of the substances
in the cells will occur and the proteids will break down with the
formation of amido-bodies, while other chemical changes, strictly
predictable if our knowledge of organic chemistry were more complete
than it is, would also occur. Putrefactive and fermentative bacteria
will attack the proteids, fats, and carbohydrates, and in the end our
aggregation of chemical substances will become an aggregation of much
simpler compounds--water, carbon dioxide, marsh gas, sulphuretted
hydrogen, phosphoretted hydrogen, ammonia, nitrates, etc., all of
which will dissolve in the water of the pond, or will diffuse into
the adjacent atmosphere. But in the living embryo this is not what
occurs: an entirely different, and much more complex, arrangement of
the chemical substances originally present in the segmented egg, or
at least a physical and chemical re-arrangement, is brought about.
The entelechy of the developing embryo prevents some reactions from
occurring and directs the energy which is potential in the system
towards the performance of other reactions.
Two analogies, suggested by Driesch, will perhaps make the rôle of
entelechy more clear. A workman, a heap of bricks, some mortar, some
food, and some oxygen constitute a system in the physico-chemical
sense. From his heap of bricks and mortar the workman may build one of
several different kinds of small house, or he may perhaps construct
several walls without any definite arrangement, or he may merely
convert one “disorderly” heap of bricks and mortar into another
“disorderly” heap. In the same way a man, a case of movable types, some
food, and some oxygen constitute another system. The initial phase of
this system consists of the compositor, his food, and some fifty-odd
boxes of types, each of which contains a large number of similar
elements. A final phase of the system may be the arrangement of the
types to form an epic poem, or a series of dramatic criticisms, or a
meaningless jumble of correctly spelt words. In all these cases the
same amount of energy was expended: the bricklayer used up the same
quantity of food and oxygen and excreted the same quantities of water,
carbon dioxide, and urea, whether he made a house, or a small chimney,
or a heap of bricks without architectural arrangement. The system of
bricks and mortar acquired during the process of differentiation a
gradually increasing complexity; while in the case of the type-setting
the diversity of arrangement acquired in the final phases may be of a
very high order. Yet the intelligent mind of the worker remained in
either case unchanged.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account