It is only in our own times that Biology has become sceptical and has
begun to doubt whether its earlier Philosophy is a sound one. That
which it describes--the object-matter of its Science--is not that which
Physics describes. There are two domains of Givenness, the organic
and the inorganic. Biology, leaning on Physics, studied motions and
transformations, just as Physics did, though the motions which it
studied were more complex and the transformations more mysterious. But
borrowing the methods of investigation of Physics it borrowed also
its Philosophy, and so it placed behind its Givenness the Reality
that Physics at first postulated and then abandoned. The organism was
therefore a material system actuated by energy. The notion, it should
be noted, is not a deduction from the results of Biology, but only from
its methods.
Did Physiology, that is, the Physiology of the Schools, ever really
investigate the organism? A muscle-nerve preparation, an excised kidney
through which blood is perfused, an exposed salivary gland which is
stimulated, even a frog deprived of its cerebral hemispheres--these
things are not organisms. They are not permanent centres of action,
autonomous physico-chemical constellations capable of independent
existence, and capable of indefinite growth by dissociation. They
are parts of the organism, which, having received the impulse of
life, an impulse which soon becomes exhausted, exhibit for a time
some of the phenomena of the organism. What Physiology did attain
in such investigations was an analytical description of some of the
activities of the organism. It did not describe life, but rather
the physico-chemical reactions in which life is manifested. The
description, it should be noted, is all-important for the human race
in its effort to acquire mastery over its environment; and there is
no other way in which it may be carried further but by the methods of
physical Science. Givenness is one, though we arbitrarily divide it
into the domains of the organic and the inorganic, and there can be
only one way of describing it. That is the mechanistic method.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account