The place of magic in the intellectual history of EuropeThorndike, Lynn
History
The place of magic in the intellectual history of Europe
Thorndike, Lynn
Magic -- Europe -- History
He who gathers the iris should be in a state of chastity. Three months
beforehand let him soak the ground around the plant with hydromel—as a
sort of atonement to appease the earth. When he comes to pluck it, he
should first trace three circles about it with the point of a sword,
and, the moment he plucks it, raise it aloft towards the heavens.[89] In
another passage, in connection with the application of a mixture to an
inflammatory tumor, Pliny says that persons of experience regard it as
very important that the poultice be applied by a naked virgin and that
both she and the patient be fasting. Touching the sufferer with the back
of her hand, she is to say, “Apollo forbids a disease to increase which
a naked virgin restrains.” Then, withdrawing her hand, she is to repeat
the same words thrice and to join with the patient in spitting on the
ground each time.[90]
Pliny occasionally prefaces his marvelous remedies by some such
expression as “it is said.” This circumstance is scarcely to be taken as
a sign of mental reservation, however, as the following absurd
statement, which he makes upon his own authority and declares is easily
tested by experiment, will indicate. “If a person repents of a blow
given to another, either by hand or with a missile, let him spit at once
into the palm of the hand which inflicted the blow, and all resentment
in the person struck will instantly vanish.” This is often proved,
according to Pliny, in the case of beasts of burden, which can be
induced to increase their speed by this method after the use of the whip
has failed.[91]
One can, perhaps, make some distinction between the strange influences
which Pliny credited and the statements of the magi which he rejected. I
believe that he did not go to the length of affirming that plants or
parts of animals could cause panics, procure provisions, win you royal
favor, gain for you vengeance on your enemies, or make you invisible.
But he was inconsistent enough. After asserting that a single fish but a
few inches long could immediately arrest the progress of the largest
vessel by attaching itself to the keel of the ship,[92] was it for him
to declare false the notion that a stone can calm winds or ward off hail
and swarms of locusts? He characterized as “idle talk” the assertion of
the magi that the stone “gorgonia” counteracted fascination,[93] but he
had already written: “Id quoque convenit, quo nihil equidem libentius
crediderim, tactis omnino menstruo postibus inritas fieri magorum artes,
generis vanissimi, ut aestimare licet.”[94] Apparently, then, the only
charge which he could bring against magicians without reflecting upon
himself was that of malicious and criminal practices. His beliefs were
much like theirs.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account