The Place of Science in Modern Civilisation, and Other EssaysVeblen, Thorstein
Philosophy
The Place of Science in Modern Civilisation, and Other Essays
Veblen, Thorstein
Economics; Science
Since the machine technology has made great advances, during the
nineteenth century, and has become a cultural force of wide-reaching
consequence, the formulations of science have made another move in the
direction of impersonal matter-of-fact. The machine process has
displaced the workman as the archetype in whose image causation is
conceived by the scientific investigators. The dramatic interpretation
of natural phenomena has thereby become less anthropomorphic; it no
longer constructs the life-history of a cause working to produce a given
effect--after the manner of a skilled workman producing a piece of
wrought goods--but it constructs the life-history of a process in which
the distinction between cause and effect need scarcely be observed in an
itemised and specific way, but in which the run of causation unfolds
itself in an unbroken sequence of cumulative change. By contrast with
the pragmatic formulations of worldly wisdom these latter-day theories
of the scientists appear highly opaque, impersonal, and matter-of-fact;
but taken by themselves they must be admitted still to show the
constraint of the dramatic prepossessions that once guided the savage
myth-makers.
In so far as touches the aims and the animus of scientific inquiry, as
seen from the point of view of the scientist, it is a wholly fortuitous
and insubstantial coincidence that much of the knowledge gained under
machine-made canons of research can be turned to practical account. Much
of this knowledge is useful, or may be made so, by applying it to the
control of the processes in which natural forces are engaged. This
employment of scientific knowledge for useful ends is technology, in the
broad sense in which the term includes, besides the machine industry
proper, such branches of practice as engineering, agriculture, medicine,
sanitation, and economic reforms. The reason why scientific theories can
be turned to account for these practical ends is not that these ends are
included in the scope of scientific inquiry. These useful purposes lie
outside the scientist's interest. It is not that he aims, or can aim, at
technological improvements. His inquiry is as "idle" as that of the
Pueblo myth-maker. But the canons of validity under whose guidance he
works are those imposed by the modern technology, through habituation to
its requirements; and therefore his results are available for the
technological purpose. His canons of validity are made for him by the
cultural situation; they are habits of thought imposed on him by the
scheme of life current in the community in which he lives; and under
modern conditions this scheme of life is largely machine-made. In the
modern culture, industry, industrial processes, and industrial products
have progressively gained upon humanity, until these creations of man's
ingenuity have latterly come to take the dominant place in the cultural
scheme; and it is not too much to say that they have become the chief
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account