The Place of Science in Modern Civilisation, and Other Essays — John Shaqi
The Place of Science in Modern Civilisation, and Other EssaysVeblen, Thorstein
Philosophy
The Place of Science in Modern Civilisation, and Other Essays
Veblen, Thorstein
Economics; Science
It is commonly held that modern Christendom is superior to any and all
other systems of civilised life. Other ages and other cultural regions
are by contrast spoken of as lower, or more archaic, or less mature. The
claim is that the modern culture is superior on the whole, not that it
is the best or highest in all respects and at every point. It has, in
fact, not an all-around superiority, but a superiority within a closely
limited range of intellectual activities, while outside this range many
other civilisations surpass that of the modern occidental peoples. But
the peculiar excellence of the modern culture is of such a nature as to
give it a decisive practical advantage over all other cultural schemes
that have gone before or that have come into competition with it. It has
proved itself fit to survive in a struggle for existence as against
those civilisations which differ from it in respect of its distinctive
traits.
Modern civilisation is peculiarly matter-of-fact. It contains many
elements that are not of this character, but these other elements do not
belong exclusively or characteristically to it. The modern civilised
peoples are in a peculiar degree capable of an impersonal, dispassionate
insight into the material facts with which mankind has to deal. The apex
of cultural growth is at this point. Compared with this trait the rest
of what is comprised in the cultural scheme is adventitious, or at the
best it is a by-product of this hard-headed apprehension of facts. This
quality may be a matter of habit or of racial endowment, or it may be an
outcome of both; but whatever be the explanation of its prevalence, the
immediate consequence is much the same for the growth of civilisation. A
civilisation which is dominated by this matter-of-fact insight must
prevail against any cultural scheme that lacks this element. This
characteristic of western civilisation comes to a head in modern
science, and it finds its highest material expression in the technology
of the machine industry. In these things modern culture is creative and
self-sufficient; and these being given, the rest of what may seem
characteristic in western civilisation follows by easy consequence. The
cultural structure clusters about this body of matter-of-fact knowledge
as its substantial core. Whatever is not consonant with these opaque
creations of science is an intrusive feature in the modern scheme,
borrowed or standing over from the barbarian past.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account