The Place of Science in Modern Civilisation, and Other EssaysVeblen, Thorstein
Philosophy
The Place of Science in Modern Civilisation, and Other Essays
Veblen, Thorstein
Economics; Science
The requisite knowledge and proficiency of ways and means is a product,
perhaps a by-product, of the life of the community at large; and it can
also be maintained and retained only by the community at large. Whatever
may be true for the unsearchable prehistoric phases of the life-history
of the race, it appears to be true for the most primitive human groups
and phases of which there is available information that the mass of
technological knowledge possessed by any community, and necessary to its
maintenance and to the maintenance of each of its members or subgroups,
is too large a burden for any one individual or any single line of
descent to carry. This holds true, of course, all the more rigorously
and consistently, the more advanced the "state of the industrial arts"
may be. But it seems to hold true with a generality that is fairly
startling, that whenever a given cultural community is broken up or
suffers a serious diminution of numbers, its technological heritage
deteriorates and dwindles, even though it may have been apparently
meager enough before. On the other hand, it seems to hold true with a
similar uniformity that, when an individual member or a fraction of a
community on what we call a lower stage of economic development is drawn
away and trained and instructed in the ways of a larger and more
efficient technology, and is then thrown back into his home community,
such an individual or fraction proves unable to make head against the
technological bent of the community at large or even to create a serious
diversion. Slight, perhaps transient, and gradually effective
technological consequences may result from such an experiment; but they
become effective by diffusion and assimilation through the body of the
community, not in any marked degree in the way of an exceptional
efficiency on the part of the individual or fraction which has been
subjected to exceptional training. And inheritance in technological
matters runs not in the channels of consanguinity, but in those of
tradition and habituation, which are necessarily as wide as the scheme
of life of the community. Even in a relatively small and primitive
community the mass of detail comprised in its knowledge and practice of
ways and means is large,--too large for any one individual or household
to become competently expert in it all; and its ramifications are
extensive and diverse, at the same time that all these ramifications
bear, directly or indirectly, on the life and work of each member of the
community. Neither the standard and routine of living nor the daily work
of any individual in the community would remain the same after the
introduction of an appreciable change, for good or ill, in any branch of
the community's equipment of technological expedients. If the community
grows larger, to the dimensions of a modern civilised people, and this
immaterial equipment grows proportionately great and various, then it
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account