The Position of Woman in Primitive Society: A Study of the MatriarchyHartley, C. Gasquoine (Catherine Gasquoine)
History
The Position of Woman in Primitive Society: A Study of the Matriarchy
Hartley, C. Gasquoine (Catherine Gasquoine)
Matriarchy; Women -- History
There is a splendid imaginative appeal in this remarkable passage.
Again the italics are mine. It is, of course, impossible to accept
this statement, as Bachofen does, as an historical account of what
happened through the agency of women at the time of which he is
treating. Yet, we can find a suggestion of truth that is eternal. Is
there not here a kind of prophetic foretelling of every struggle
towards readjustment in the relationships of the two sexes, through
all the periods of civilisation, from the beginning until now? You
will see what I mean. The essential fact for woman--and also for
man--is the sense of community with the race. Neither sex can keep a
position apart from parenthood. Just in so far as the mother and the
father attain to consciousness and responsibility in their relations
to the race do they reach development and power. Bachofen, as a poet,
understood this; to me, at least, it is the something real that
underlies all the delusion of his work. But I diverge a little in
making these comments.
Again the origin of the change from the first period of matriarchy is
sought by Bachofen in religion.
“Each stage of development was marked by its peculiar
religious ideas, produced by the dissatisfaction with which
the dominating idea of the previous stage was regarded; a
dissatisfaction which led to a disappearance of this
condition.” “What was gained by religion, fostering the
cause of women, by assigning a mystical and almost divine
character to motherhood was now lost through the same cause.
The loss came in the Greek era. Dionysus started the idea of
the divinity of fatherhood; holding the father to be the
child’s true parent, and the mother merely the nurse.” In
this way, we are asked to believe, the rights of men arose,
the father came to be the chief parent, the head of the
mother and the owner of the children, and, therefore, the
parent through whom kinship was traced. We learn that, at
first, “women opposed this new gospel of fatherhood, and
fresh Amazonian risings were the common feature of their
opposition.” But the resistance was fruitless. “Jason put an
end to the rule of the Amazons in Lemnos. Dionysus and
Bellerophon strove together passionately, yet without
gaining a decisive victory, until Apollo, with calm
superiority, finally became the conqueror, and the father
gained the power that before had belonged to the
mother.”[21]
[21] _Das Mutterrecht_, pp. 73, 85. Compare also McLennan,
_Studies_, p. 322, and Starcke, _The Primitive Family in its
Origin and Development_.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account