Lord Kelvin writing in 1893, in his preface to the English edition of
Hertz’s Researches on Electric Waves, says “many workers and many
thinkers have helped to build up the nineteenth century school of
_plenum_, one ether for light, heat, electricity, magnetism; and the
German and English volumes containing Hertz’s electrical papers, given
to the world in the last decade of the century, will be a permanent
monument of the splendid consummation now realised.”
Ten years later, in 1905, we find Einstein declaring that “the ether
will be proved to be superfluous.” At first sight the revolution in
scientific thought brought about in the course of a single decade
appears to be almost too violent. A more careful even though a rapid
review of the subject will, however, show how the Theory of Relativity
gradually became a historical necessity.
Towards the beginning of the nineteenth century, the luminiferous ether
came into prominence as a result of the brilliant successes of the wave
theory in the hands of Young and Fresnel. In its stationary aspect the
elastic solid ether was the outcome of the search for a medium in which
the light waves may “undulate.” This stationary ether, as shown by
Young, also afforded a satisfactory explanation of astronomical
aberration. But its very success gave rise to a host of new questions
all bearing on the central problem of relative motion of ether and
matter.
_Arago’s prism experiment._—The refractive index of a glass prism
depends on the incident velocity of light outside the prism and its
velocity inside the prism after refraction. On Fresnel’s fixed ether
hypothesis, the incident light waves are situated in the stationary
ether outside the prism and move with velocity _c_ with respect to the
ether. If the prism moves with a velocity _u_ with respect to this fixed
ether, then the incident velocity of light with respect to the prism
should be _c_ + _u_. Thus the refractive index of the glass prism should
depend on _u_ the absolute velocity of the prism, _i.e._, its velocity
with respect to the fixed ether. Arago performed the experiment in 1819,
but failed to detect the expected change.
_Airy-Boscovitch water-telescope experiment._—Boscovitch had still
earlier in 1766, raised the very important question of the dependence of
aberration on the refractive index of the medium filling the telescope.
Aberration depends on the difference in the velocity of light outside
the telescope and its velocity inside the telescope. If the latter
velocity changes owing to a change in the medium filling the telescope,
aberration itself should change, that is, aberration should depend on
the nature of the medium.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account