The modifications proposed independently by Hertz and Heaviside fare no
better.[1] They postulated the actual medium to be the seat of all
electric polarisation and further emphasised the reciprocal relation
subsisting between electricity and magnetism, thus making the field
equations more symmetrical. On this view the whole of the polarised
ether is carried away by the moving medium, and consequently, the
convection coefficient naturally becomes unity in this theory, a value
quite as discrepant as that obtained on the original Maxwellian
assumption.
Thus neither Maxwell’s original theory nor its subsequent modifications
as developed by Hertz and Heaviside succeeded in obtaining a value for
Fresnelian coefficient equal to 1 - (1/μ^2), and consequently stood
totally condemned from the optical point of view.
Certain direct electromagnetic experiments involving relative motion of
polarised dielectrics were no less conclusive against the generalised
theory of Hertz and Heaviside. According to Hertz a moving dielectric
would carry away the whole of its electric displacement with it. Hence
the electromagnetic effect near the moving dielectric would be
proportional to the total electric displacement, that is to K, the
specific inductive capacity of the dielectric. In 1901, Blondlot working
with a stream of moving gas could not detect any such effect. H. A.
Wilson repeated the experiment in an improved form in 1903 and working
with ebonite found that the observed effect was proportional to K - 1
instead of to K. For gases K is nearly equal to 1 and hence practically
no effect will be observed in their case. This gives a satisfactory
explanation of Blondlot’s negative results.
Rowland had shown in 1876 that the magnetic force due to a rotating
condenser (the dielectric remaining stationary) was proportional to K,
the sp. ind. cap. On the other hand, Röntgen found in 1888 the magnetic
effect due to a rotating dielectric (the condenser remaining stationary)
to be proportional to K - 1, and not to K. Finally Eichenwald in 1903
found that when both condenser and dielectric are rotated together, the
effect observed was quite independent of K, a result quite consistent
with the two previous experiments. The Rowland effect proportional to K,
together with the opposite Röntgen effect proportional to 1 - K, makes
the Eichenwald effect independent of K.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account