The Principles of Stratigraphical GeologyMarr, J. E. (John Edward)
Science
The Principles of Stratigraphical Geology
Marr, J. E. (John Edward)
Geology, Stratigraphic
It cannot be assumed that the stratum _A_ is therefore contemporaneous
with _A´_, _B_ with _B´_, and _C_ with _C´_, but on the other hand, it
must not be assumed that they are not contemporaneous. This is a
statement which requires some comment. It has been urged that if the
deposits _A_ and _A´_ in different localities contain the same fauna,
this is a proof that the two are not contemporaneous, for some time
must have elapsed in order to allow of the migration of the organisms
from one area to another, it being justifiably assumed that they did
not originate simultaneously in the two areas. But everything depends
on the time taken for migration as compared with the period of
existence of the fauna. If the former was extremely short as compared
with the latter it may be practically ignored, for we might then speak
of the strata as contemporaneous, just as a historian would rightly
speak of events in the same way which occurred upon the same
afternoon, though one might have happened an hour before the other.
Let us then glance at the evidence which we have at our disposal,
which bears upon this matter.
The objection to identification of strata with similar faunas as
contemporaneous was urged by Whewell, Herbert Spencer, and Huxley, and
the latter suggested the term Homotaxis or similarity of arrangement
as applicable to groups of strata in different areas, in which a
similar succession of faunas was traceable, maintaining that though
not contemporaneous the strata might be spoken of as homotaxial.
Huxley went so far as to assert that "for anything that geology or
palæontology are able to show to the contrary, a Devonian fauna and
flora in the British Islands may have been contemporaneous with
Silurian life in North America, and with a Carboniferous fauna and
flora in Africa[13]," a statement which few if any living geologists
will endorse. If the statement be true, and the fauna which we speak
of as Devonian, when present be always found (as it is) above that
which we in Britain know as Silurian and below that which we term
Carboniferous, the faunas must have originated independently in the
three centres, and disappeared before the appearance of the next
fauna, or having originated at the same centre, each must have
migrated in the same direction, spread over the world, and become
extinct as it reached the point or line from which it started. Suppose
for instance a fauna _A_ originates at the meridian of Greenwich,
migrates eastward, and dies out again when it once more reaches
Greenwich, that _B_ and _C_ do the same, at a later period, then the
fauna _B_ will always be found above _A_ and _C_ above _B_, but if
_B_ did not become extinct when it reached the Greenwich meridian, it
would continue its eastward course, and _C_ having in the meantime
started on its first round, the fossils of the fauna _B_ would be
found both above and below those of _C_. It will be shown below that
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account