The Problem of 'Edwin Drood': A Study in the Methods of DickensNicoll, W. Robertson (William Robertson), Sir
General
The Problem of 'Edwin Drood': A Study in the Methods of Dickens
Nicoll, W. Robertson (William Robertson), Sir
Cathedrals in literature; Dickens, Charles, 1812-1870. Mystery of Edwin Drood; Murder in literature
The lustrous gipsy-face drooped over the clinging arms and bosom, and
the wild black hair fell down protectingly over the childish form.
There was a slumbering gleam of fire in the intense dark eyes, though
they were then softened with compassion and admiration. Let
whomsoever it most concerned look well to it!
This last sentence is another of the unmistakably prophetic sentences in
Dickens. Helena was the sworn champion thenceforth of Rosa against
Jasper. Helena submits herself to the fairy bride and learns from her
what she knows. When Jasper is mentioned and Rosa says, ‘I could not
hold any terms with him, could I?’ Helena answers with indignation, ‘You
know how I love you, darling. But I would sooner see you dead at his
wicked feet.’
As to the close and tender affection between Helena and Neville, and her
vehement sympathy with his trial, there is no question. I quote one
passage because it seems to me a most striking fact that in the proofs of
Dickens the whole of it is struck out:
‘I don’t think so,’ said the Minor Canon. ‘There is duty to be done
here; and there are womanly feeling, sense, and courage wanted here.’
‘I meant,’ explained Neville, ‘that the surroundings are so dull and
unwomanly, and that Helena can have no suitable friend or society
here.’
‘You have only to remember,’ said Mr. Crisparkle, ‘that you are here
yourself, and that she has to draw you into the sunlight.’
They were silent for a little while, and then Mr. Crisparkle began
anew.
‘When we first spoke together, Neville, you told me that your sister
had risen out of the disadvantages of your past lives as superior to
you as the tower of Cloisterham Cathedral is higher than the chimneys
of Minor Canon Corner. Do you remember that?’
‘Right well!’
‘I was inclined to think it at the time an enthusiastic flight. No
matter what I think it now. What I would emphasise is, that under
the head of Pride your sister is a great and opportune example to
you.’
‘Under _all_ heads that are included in the composition of a fine
character, she is.’
‘Say so; but take this one. . . . She can dominate it even when it
is wounded through her sympathy with you. . . . Every day and hour
of her life since Edwin Drood’s disappearance she has faced malignity
and folly for you as only a brave nature well directed can. So it
will be with her to the end . . . [pride] which knows no shrinking,
and can get no mastery over her.’
Immediately after, Neville says: ‘I will do all I can to imitate her.’
‘Do so, and be a truly brave man, as she is a truly brave woman,’
answered Mr. Crisparkle stoutly. In his proof Dickens struck out the
words, ‘as she is a truly brave woman.’
It is impossible, I think, to read this and not to see that Dickens is
afraid that we may too soon suspect Helena Landless of being Datchery.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account