It seems to me that the aforementioned demand amounts to a waste of
energy which, in view of economic conditions, does not seem justified.
Although analytical training invades the field of medical training, it
neither includes this training, nor is included by it. If a
psychoanalytical college were to be organized, which today may strike
one as being a fantastic idea, the curriculum of this institution would
have to include much of what is taught in medical schools. Aside from
the Psychology of the Depths, which would naturally always be the main
subject taught, Biology would have to be included in the course, and
Science of Sex would also be one of the major subjects. In addition,
adequate instruction would have to be given on such disturbances which
belong in the realm of Psychiatry. Psychoanalytical training would have
to include a number of subjects which have no connection with medicine,
and never enter the physician’s practice, such as History of
Civilization, Mythology, Psychology of Religion, and Literature. Without
being well acquainted with these subjects, the analyst will be unable to
grasp the problems that will face him in the course of his practice.
Most of the subjects, however, belonging to medical training, will not
be of any use to him and although all this knowledge is highly valuable
for those who need it, it would not assist the analyst to understand a
neurotic condition nor to alleviate it. In case the objection is made
here that specialists in other fields of medical endeavor, also do not
need all the details they acquire in the course of their training, it
must be said that such a case could not be considered analogous. For
many branches of medicine, such facts as, for example, Pathology
presents, are of great importance. The analyst, however, reaches out for
a variety of experiences, with different phenomena, underlying different
laws. Although philosophy may succeed in bridging the chasm between body
and soul, as far as our own experience is concerned, this chasm,
nevertheless, exists, presenting itself in an especially striking light,
as regards our practical endeavors.
It seems unjust and impractical to force a person to take a roundabout
route via medical training, if this person be bent upon relieving
another individual from the agonies of a phobia or a fixed idea.
Moreover, such a procedure would be ineffective, as long as
psychoanalysis in general is not suppressed.
Just imagine that somewhere in the country, there is a certain mountain
top that can be reached by two different roads, the one being short and
straight, and the other long and winding. An attempt is made to block
the short road by a “no-trespass” sign. There is some chance of this
sign being respected, if the short road is steep and difficult to climb,
whereas the long road is easy to travel. However, if the detour should
be the more difficult road, you can easily surmise how little the
trespassing sign would be respected.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account