is a judgment of fact, if it asserts existence, so also does error.
The pragmatist principle has an important bearing on religion. It
justifies the Faith attitude. It shows that the good aimed at by a
"truth claim" is only attainable by the exercise of the will to
believe. Thus it replaces the intellectual maxim, Believe in nothing
you can possibly doubt, with the practical maxim, Resolve not to quench
any impulse to believe because doubts of the truth are possible.
Belief may even be a condition of the success of the truth claim.
CHAPTER VI
UTILITY
We have seen in the last chapter that pragmatism is both a criticism
and a theory. It shows us that the {56} notion that truth is
correspondence involves the conception of an "impossible" knowledge,
and the notion that truth is coherence or consistency involves the
conception of a "useless" knowledge. The explanation pragmatism itself
offers is of the kind that is called in the technical language of
philosophy teleological. This means that to explain or to give a
meaning to truth all we can do is to point out the purpose on account
of which it exists. This is not scientific explanation. Physical
science explains a fact or an event by showing the conditions which
give rise to it or that determine its character. Pragmatism recognises
no conditions determining truth such as those which science embodies in
the conception of a natural law--that is, the idea of a connection of
natural events with one another which is not dependent on human
thoughts about them nor on human purposes in regard to them. Truth is
in intimate association with human practical activity; its meaning lies
wholly in its utility. We must therefore now examine somewhat closely
this notion of utility.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account