argument is the insight that everyone may obtain of the reality of his
own life as continuous movement, unceasing change, wherein all that
exists exists together in a present activity. To develop this argument
would exceed the limits of this book, and would be outside its purpose.
It is essential, however, that such a theory should be understood, for
clearly it is possible to hold not only that we are subject to
illusion, but that illusion is of the very nature of intellectual
apprehension. If, then, the understanding works illusion for the sake
of action, is it thereby disqualified as an instrument for the
attainment of truth?
We are brought, then, to the critical point of our inquiry. If
illusion is the essential condition of human activity, if the
intellect, the very instrument of truth, {72} is itself affected, what
is to save us from universal scepticism? If the salt have lost his
savour, wherewith shall it be salted? The intellect with its frames
and moulds shapes living change and movement into fixed immobile
states; the process of knowing alters profoundly the reality known.
Must we not conclude that knowledge, however useful, is not true? And
to what shall we turn for truth? There is, indeed, if this be so, a
deeper irony in the question, What is truth? than even Pilate could
have imagined. We have absolutely no practical concern with truth--we
must leave it to the mystic, to the unpractical, the contemplative man
who has turned aside from the stern task of busy life.
It is not so. The problem that seems so fundamental admits a quite
simple solution. Illusion is not error, nor is it falsehood; it is the
appearance of reality. It is the reality that appears, and when we
grasp the principle of utility we understand the shape that the
appearance must assume. This shape may seem to us a distortion, but in
recognising appearance we are in touch with reality, and practical
interest is the key that opens to us the interpretation of intellectual
experience. And it is not only by the intellect that we interpret the
nature of reality, for besides logic there is life, and in life we
directly perceive the reality that in logic we think about.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account