The classical work on what I have called the modern idealist doctrine
(I have avoided the word intellectualist) is Mr. F. H. Bradley's
_Appearance and Reality_. I have attempted to give the main lines of
the theory in my chapter on "The Absolute." Although it is a book for
advanced students, it is not a closed volume even to the uninstructed.
The brilliant dialectical skill of the {92} author is acknowledged and
may be enjoyed by those who reject or may fail to understand his
conclusion. Mr. Harold H. Joachim's _The Nature of Truth_ (Oxford,
Clarendon Press) is a most able and scholarly argument for the
coherence theory of truth.
The principal expositions of Pragmatism are the works of William James
and of Dr. F. C. S. Schiller. William James' _The Will to Believe_ was
the first distinct formulation of the principle. _Pragmatism, a New
Name for some Old Ways of Thinking_, is the fullest and most systematic
statement of the doctrine. _The Meaning of Truth_ is a defence of the
doctrine against the criticism that had been meted out to it
unsparingly. All three books are published by Longmans.
Dr. F. C. S. Schiller is uncompromising in his advocacy of a complete
return to the doctrine taught in the ancient world by Protagoras. He
has defended that philosopher against the arguments of Plato in a
polemical pamphlet entitled _Plato or Protagoras?_ (Oxford, Blackwell).
An Essay on "Axioms as Postulates" in _Personal Idealism_ (Macmillan &
Co.), and two volumes of collected essays on _Humanism_ (Macmillan &
Co.), set forth the doctrine, which he prefers to call Humanism, with
great force, abundant illustration, and the relief of no small amount
of humour.
For an account of the theories of Bergson, I may mention my own little
book in this series, _Henri Bergson: The Philosophy of Change_. M.
Bergson's books are _Time and Freewill_, _Matter and Memory_, and
_Creative Evolution_. To these has been recently added _An
Introduction to Metaphysics_ (Macmillan, 1912). It is the
republication in English of an article written in 1903, which has been
for a long time out of print. It is a short and clear statement of the
doctrine of Intuition.
{93}
The important studies of Professor G. F. Stout are not easily
accessible to the general reader, as they consist in contributions to
philosophical journals and proceedings of learned societies. The essay
referred to in the last chapter, "Some Fundamental Points in the Theory
of Knowledge," is in the _St. Andrews Quincentenary Publications_, 1911
(Maclehose). I may mention also his essay on "Error" in _Personal
Idealism_, noticed above, and "The Object of Thought and Real Being,"
in _Proceedings of the Aristotelian Society_, 1911.
{94}
INDEX
NDX
Bergson, Mons. Henri, 63, 69, 73, 89
Berkeley, 20, 32, 73
Coherence Theory, 25, 27
Correspondence Theory, 24, 27
Discovery of Planet Neptune, 59
Faith-attitude of Pragmatism, 55
Formal Logic, 10
Hegel, 44
Hume, 30
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account