The Propaganda for Reform in Proprietary Medicines, Vol. 1 of 2Council on Pharmacy and Chemistry (American Medical Association)
Science
The Propaganda for Reform in Proprietary Medicines, Vol. 1 of 2
Council on Pharmacy and Chemistry (American Medical Association)
Patent medicines
First, however, we shall take this opportunity to publish some matter
which we have had in reserve since the first exposé was made last
October. When it was realized that Mr. Tyree intended to defend himself
by claiming that a change had recently been made in the powder, we took
occasion to try to secure some of the preparation that had been on the
market for a long time. In this we succeeded very well. From a Chicago
druggist one package was bought which had been in the store at least
since July, 1902--how much longer is not known. The druggist from whom
the powder was obtained bought the drug store in July, 1902, and this
powder was on hand at that time, none having been bought since. This
particular powder was analyzed by a chemist, who found the composition
practically the same as that given in the Council’s report, this
chemist estimating that it contained approximately 81 per cent. boric
acid and 14 per cent. anhydrous zinc sulphate. Bearing in mind that for
at least four years and ten months Tyree’s Powder has been essentially
the same as it is today, this letter is very interesting: (The comments
in brackets are, of course, ours.)
“J. S. TYREE,
“Chemist,
“WASHINGTON, D. C.
“April 16, 1907.
“Dr. --------,
“----,
“_My Dear Sir_:--Doctors and medical publications of extreme and
prejudicial minds often hold and express opinions in honorable
faith, but like all critics, they are not always familiar with
the conditions composing their opinions, and are often given to
expressing them without knowledge of the true motives and facts in
the case.
“If you will read an article that appeared in one of the medical
weeklies some time ago [The Journal of the American Medical
Association, of course] and which has been copied by several of its
offsprings [not many we regret to say] relating to Tyree’s Antiseptic
Powder, you will see that I had previously informed the editor as
well as his council of investigators, that at the suggestion of
prominent physicians, extensive clinical experimenting [sic] were
being made with some slight [! ! !] changes in my powder, the object
being to develop and extend its usefulness in new lines [It had
already been recommended for about everything[2]] and at the same
time make it more acceptable to the general run of the profession.
I also notified this editor that these investigations would not be
completed until the first of the present year, after which time
these slight [! ! !] changes in the formula of Tyree’s Powder would
be announced. [It is now the middle of May; when and where were the
changes announced?[3]]
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account