The Propaganda for Reform in Proprietary Medicines, Vol. 1 of 2Council on Pharmacy and Chemistry (American Medical Association)
Science
The Propaganda for Reform in Proprietary Medicines, Vol. 1 of 2
Council on Pharmacy and Chemistry (American Medical Association)
Patent medicines
The chief claims for its therapeutic value are based on the radium
content, yet the discrepancies and contradictions, regarding this are
serious.
In connection with the reconsideration of this product the agent
presented a certificate of chemical examination by the Lederle
Laboratories in which the following statement was made as to the
radio-activity:
“Examination shows the preparation to possess slight radioactivity,
corresponding in activity to less than 1-10,000 of 1 milligram
of radium bromid per ampule. According to the sworn statement of
Dr. A. de Szendeffy, the originator of Dioradin, the preparation
contains 10 drops of radium chlorid solution (1 milligram in
100 cubic centimeters of water) in 100 cubic centimeters of the
preparation. This would correspond to 5-1,000 milligram of radium
chlorid in 100 cubic centimeters, or about 1-20,000 of 1 milligram
per ampule.”
A cursory reading of this paragraph gives the impression that Dioradin
possesses fully the amount of radio-activity claimed by its originator,
Dr. A. de Szendeffy. This impression is greatly strengthened by the
concluding paragraph of the Lederle report, which says:
“In conclusion, our examination shows that the preparation
submitted to us as Dioradin possesses radio-activity, and contains
a fixed oil (apparently expressed oil of almond), iodoform, menthol
and ether, thus confirming the sworn statement of Dr. A. de
Szendeffy in regard to the composition of this product.”
On inquiry as to the method used by the Lederle Laboratories, in
determining radio-activity the agent submitted a further statement
of the Lederle Laboratories which describes the gamma ray test by
which the determination was made and a radium value equivalent to
0.000041 mg. of radium bromid per capsule was obtained. The report then
says:
“The variations of the single measurements from the mean in the
case of the natural leak and the leak with the Dioradin near were
so large that we did not feel justified in assigning much accuracy
to the figure, 0.000041, but stated that the amount of radium per
capsule could not be greater than 0.0001 mg., with the possibility
of there being a much smaller amount present.”
It is evident that the wording of the reports of the Lederle
Laboratories is liable to give the impression that their examination
confirms the claims made for Dioradin.
It is further evident from these reports that the amount of
radio-active matter has not been definitely ascertained but that it
is at the best very small. The unreliability of the claims for radium
content of Dioradin was recently shown by Buechner,[43] who found a
specimen obtained from an apothecary to contain but 1-1,000 of the
amount claimed.
[43] Buechner: Pharm. Weekblad, March 2, 1912, p. 161.
VOLATILE AND NON-VOLATILE MATTER
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account