The Propaganda for Reform in Proprietary Medicines, Vol. 1 of 2Council on Pharmacy and Chemistry (American Medical Association)
Science
The Propaganda for Reform in Proprietary Medicines, Vol. 1 of 2
Council on Pharmacy and Chemistry (American Medical Association)
Patent medicines
In a circular contained in the package these claims were made:
“The preparations of the Dioradin are based on the miraculous
effects which scientific researches have shown in regard to the
different sicknesses treated with radium.
“It is generally known that radium, even if externally employed,
has proved itself to be a bactericidal remedy. Its effect is
multiplied if one employs it internally even in infinitesimal
doses, in consequence of its permanent action of emanation on the
organism.
“The preparations of the Dioradin contain the radium itself. For
this reason their antiseptic and bactericidal effect is much more
intensive than with medicaments which contain only its emanation,
which disappears in a short time.”
In view of the general extravagance of the claims made for its
therapeutic action the preparation was rejected without considering
other possible conflicts with the rules of the Council.
_SECOND SUBMISSION OF DIORADIN_
Having been advised of the rejection by the Council of Dioradin the
American agency, which in the meantime had become the Dioradin Co.,
requested further consideration. The Council therefore took up the
subject again. After certain typographical errors had been corrected
the following was now given as the composition:
“1 gram Iodoform.
5 grams Menthol.
10 drops Radium Chlorid Solution (containing 1 milligram of
radium chlorid in 100 cubic centimeters of water).
5 grams Ether.
89 grams expressed oil of almond.
This liquid is put up in ampules containing one cubic
centimeter of liquid.”
In support of the therapeutic claims for Dioradin the American agent
submitted literature consisting chiefly of articles by Dr. Bernheim
of Paris. Before reporting on the requested reconsideration of
Dioradin the referee directed the secretary of the Council to point
out to the American agent that in the formula given, the amount
of non-volatile matter should be about 90 per cent., whereas the
report of the Lederle Laboratories which accompanied the request for
reconsideration states that but 72.08 per cent. was found in the
analysis. In reply the agent stated that he had called the attention
of Dr. Szendeffy (the originator of Dioradin) to the discrepancies
concerning non-volatile matter and that he felt sure the discrepancy
was wholly accidental (_sic_). In a later communication the agent
submitted a statement of analysis from the Lederle Laboratories
of a new specimen of Dioradin according to which the amount of
non-volatile matter agreed essentially with the amount claimed by the
agent.
The referee, having examined the evidence, is of the opinion that
the statement of composition is misleading and that the therapeutic
claims are unwarranted, thus:
DISCREPANCIES IN RADIUM CONTENT
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account