The Propaganda for Reform in Proprietary Medicines, Vol. 1 of 2Council on Pharmacy and Chemistry (American Medical Association)
Science
The Propaganda for Reform in Proprietary Medicines, Vol. 1 of 2
Council on Pharmacy and Chemistry (American Medical Association)
Patent medicines
Echtisia (Wm. S. Merrell Chemical Co.), Ecthol (Battle and Co.) and
Echitone (Strong, Cobb and Co.) are proprietary preparations each of
which is alleged to contain echinacea as its chief constituent. In 1909
the Council examined into the claims made for echinacea. This drug has
been claimed to be a “specific” for rattlesnake bite, syphilis, typhoid
fever, malaria, diphtheria and hydrophobia. Enthusiasts have credited
it with equally certain curative effects in tuberculosis, tetanus,
and exophthalmic goiter and with power of retarding the development
of cancer. Of course there is no reliable or trustworthy evidence to
substantiate these claims. Echinacea is not often prescribed under its
own name, but is employed as an ingredient in proprietary preparations
mixed with other little-used or obsolete substances. Thus Echtisia is
said to contain echinacea, wild indigo, arbor vitae and poke root;
Ecthol, to have echinacea and arbor vitae; Echitone, to consist of
echinacea, pansy and blue flag. Naturally the manufacturers of such
proprietaries make use of all available optimistic reports in promoting
their sale, while each manufacturer ascribes special and peculiar
virtues to the combination represented in his particular preparation.
The Merrell Chemical Company claims that baptisia (wild indigo) is a
“destroyer” of devitalizing elements in the blood “a vitalizer of the
blood as well”; that thuja (arbor vitae) is a “perfect antiseptic and a
generator of vital force in disorganized tissues,” and that a long list
of diseases, including diphtheria, syphilitic sciatica and gonorrheal
rheumatism, “are all more or less amenable to full doses” of phytolacca
(poke root). Strong, Cobb and Co. maintain that Iris versicolor (blue
flag) is “one of the most powerful excitants of the biliary, salivary
and pancreatic secretions,” and that the “principal sphere of action of
Viola tricolor [pansy] is in the gastro-intestinal canal and the skin.”
There is no satisfactory evidence that the claims for any of
these substances are any more reliable than those for echinacea.
Notwithstanding, Strong, Cobb and Co. claim for Echitone “not only the
virtues of its constituent parts, but a wider field and a particular
therapeutic value of its own”; Battle and Co., maintain that Ecthol
is the “‘Ideal Corrector’ of depraved conditions of the fluids and
tissues,” while the Merrell Company urges the virtues of Echtisia in a
list of diseases ranging from acne to appendicitis and from gangrene
to rattlesnake bite. The Council refused recognition to these three
products and directed publication of reports to call attention to the
exaggerated, unwarranted and often utterly absurd claims made for these
and similar preparations.--(_From The Journal A. M. A., Jan. 2, 1915._)
ERGOAPIOL[N]
Abstract of Report of the Council on Pharmacy and Chemistry
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account