The Propaganda for Reform in Proprietary Medicines, Vol. 2 of 2Council on Pharmacy and Chemistry (American Medical Association)
Science
The Propaganda for Reform in Proprietary Medicines, Vol. 2 of 2
Council on Pharmacy and Chemistry (American Medical Association)
Patent medicines
It is claimed that the “therapeutic indications” of Minson’s Soluble
Iodin are the “same as those of all iodin and iodid preparations,
internally, externally, hypodermically and intravenously; excepting,
however, counter irritation.” It is admitted that there are no
“clinical reports” as to the hypodermic and intravenous use, but the
belief is expressed “that in an emergency it is a safe remedy under
proper dilution.” It is further claimed that “for all practical
purposes it is nontoxic and nonirritating” and that “it has none of
the undesirable features such as is the case with the iodids and the
organic preparations of iodin, proprietary or otherwise.”
It was assigned for consideration to the Committee on Pharmacology,
whose referee reported:
“According to the information submitted, this is a tincture of iodin;
differing from the official tincture in that it is more dilute and in
that hydrogen and ethyl iodid is the solvent in place of potassium
iodid. It is practically immaterial for internal administration,
whether the cation of the solvent iodid is hydrogen, ethyl, potassium
or sodium. It would certainly be inadvisable to inject a preparation
containing free iodin hypodermically. It is not ‘a safe remedy’ for
intravenous injection and it would not be nonirritant. The statement
that ‘it has none of the undesirable features’ of other iodin compounds
is inherently impossible. Apparent freedom of any iodin preparation
from undesirable effects is generally due to the use of small doses.
Such claims are plainly therapeutic exaggerations and therefore in
conflict with Rule 6. Even should these be removed, the preparation
must be held an unessential modification of the official tincture, and
therefore in conflict with Rule 10.”
The report was agreed to by the committee and adopted by the Council
and Minson’s Soluble Iodin “Kelpidine” declared inadmissible to New
and Nonofficial Remedies.--(_From Reports of Council on Pharmacy and
Chemistry, 1917, p. 152._)
NUTONE
Report of the Council on Pharmacy and Chemistry
NuTone (NuTone Company, Lowell, Mass.) is a “nutritive tonic” said to
have the following complex composition:
Cod Liver Oil, Pure Norwegian, 25 per cent.
Malt Extract, 9-1/3 per cent.
Beef juice,
Glycerine,
Hypophosphite Lime, Hypophosphite Soda, Chemically pure,
1-1/2 grs. each to the oz.
Fl. Ext. Nux Vomica, 3/64 of a minimum in each teaspoonful.
It is advertised with claims that will lead thoughtless physicians
and a confiding public to depend on it in cases in which fresh air,
hygienic surroundings and nutritious food are of prime importance.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account