The psycho-analytic study of the familyFlugel, J. C. (John Carl)
Science
The psycho-analytic study of the family
Flugel, J. C. (John Carl)
Families; Marriage; Parent and child; Psychoanalysis
Although of all the members of the family, the father, as its head, most
frequently and regularly undergoes apotheosis, the other members of the
family are not without considerable influence on the conceptions that
are formed as to the nature and qualities of divine beings. Foremost as
regards such influence, after the father, is of course the mother. In a
strict monotheism the mother elements would seem to be almost always, if
not invariably, subordinate to those of the father; the former, so far
as they are represented at all, being submerged or incorporated into the
latter[180]. But very few religions remain strictly and consistently
monotheistic; and in most of those that show tendencies towards polytheism
the mother elements are represented in a separate person or a separate
principle. Thus, both in primitive and in more advanced forms of religion
it is usual to find mother goddesses who bear the same relation to the
earthly mother as does the father-god to the earthly father.
[Sidenote: The mother-son relationship and its repression]
[Sidenote: The struggle round the mother element in Christianity]
Nevertheless, it would appear that the mother-goddess is, at a certain
stage of culture at any rate, liable to meet with opposition from which
the corresponding father-god is usually exempt. This opposition would seem
to be due to the admixture of incestuous passion which is brought over
into religion from the original attachment of the child (and especially
of course the son) to his earthly mother. The relations between mother
and son fairly often find expression in religious stories, as in the
cases of Cybele and Attis, Ishtar and Tammuz, Mary and Christ and (in the
displaced form of brother and sister love) Isis and Osiris. As a rule
however the mother-son relationship is not permanent but is disturbed and
broken by evil plottings and brutal actions on the part of some third
person (usually a father or a brother substitute), as a result of which
the young son-god often meets with his death. The relations of Attis and
of Christ to their mothers are of special interest in this connection,
inasmuch as they plainly indicate the existence of an inner inhibition on
the son's part as well as a separation brought about by interference from
without. Attis according at least to some versions of his story, unmans
himself on discovering the incestuous nature of his affection (as Œdipus
himself had done, in a symbolic form, by putting out his eyes). In Christ
the repression of the mother-regarding tendencies seems to have led to
an attitude of aloofness towards his mother, and through her towards all
women (_cp._ his words "Woman, what have I to do with thee?," John 2,
4)--an attitude that has profoundly affected his followers throughout the
ages: for in the history of the Christian religion there is evidence--even
apart from its notorious aversion from and distrust of women in
general--of the existence of a constant struggle centering round the idea
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account