The psycho-analytic study of the familyFlugel, J. C. (John Carl)
Science
The psycho-analytic study of the family
Flugel, J. C. (John Carl)
Families; Marriage; Parent and child; Psychoanalysis
(1) The reasons which are given by primitive peoples for their obedience
to the rule of exogamy are various; sometimes it is considered that harm
would come to the pair who are guilty of the forbidden union, this perhaps
being usually of the nature of some disease, or else very frequently,
impotence or barrenness; sometimes it is the offspring of the guilty pair
who will incur the penalty; quite often, however, the evil results of such
a union are supposed to affect the whole community to which they belong
and consist not uncommonly in general infertility of women, animals and
plants. These reasons, though they no doubt exercise a powerful influence
among those who hold them, are for the most part too obviously of the
nature of superstitions, inventions or rationalisations to be taken at
their face value; though the study of them on psycho-analytic principles
would no doubt bring interesting and suggestive results.
Hardly much more satisfactory, if regarded as attempts at affording
complete and ultimate explanations, are some of hypotheses that have been
put forward by modern students of exogamy.
[Sidenote: Durkheim's Theory of the sanctity of blood]
(2) Thus, Durkheim[246] suggests that exogamy arose as a result of
the religious respect for blood, particularly menstruous blood; the
divine totemic being is supposed to be resident in blood, hence blood
is sacred, especially to those of the totem clan, and no man of this
clan may trespass on the very spot where the sacred blood periodically
manifests itself. Even if this theory should afford a satisfactory
proximate explanation of exogamy, it is obviously very far from revealing
the true ultimate biological and psychological factors that have led to
the practice. Even apart from this, however, it gives rise to certain
difficulties and objections (more especially connected with the lack of
the close correspondence between exogamous classes and totemic clans which
we should expect upon this theory) and has almost certainly at best but a
very limited field of application[247].
[Sidenote: Westermarck's theory of an innate aversion to incest]
(3) Westermarck[248] would explain exogamy and the avoidance of incest
generally as due to the fact that there is an innate aversion to sexual
intercourse between persons living together from early youth, and that,
as such persons are in most cases related by blood, this feeling would
naturally display itself in custom and law as a horror of intercourse
between near kin[249].
[Sidenote: resulting from the injurious effects of inbreeding]
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account