The psycho-analytic study of the familyFlugel, J. C. (John Carl)
Science
The psycho-analytic study of the family
Flugel, J. C. (John Carl)
Families; Marriage; Parent and child; Psychoanalysis
As to the general existence of this horror there can be no doubt, and to
assign to it an important part in framing human opinions and institutions
with regard to incest is perfectly justifiable so long as we do not lose
sight of the fact that this horror is only one side of the total human
attitude towards the matter and that alongside of the horror there exists
an attraction towards incest which corresponds in intensity to that of
the horror itself[250]. An explanation in terms of this incest horror is
not, however, that which we are seeking; it is, on the contrary, the very
existence of this horror for which we are trying to account. We have to
ask, what are the conditions in human life and mind that have brought
about the widespread aversion to incest that is so generally manifested.
According to Westermarck, these conditions are to be found in the process
of natural selection; marriages between near kin are, he maintains, on
the whole injurious to the species and, therefore, through survival of
the fittest, the existing races of men show a marked aversion to such
marriages.
[Sidenote: These effects by no means certain]
In estimating the correctness of this theory, it is well to remember
that the supposed ill effects of inbreeding in men and animals are by no
means as yet universally admitted by those who have studied the subject,
and that, even so far as their existence is admitted, they are not yet
fully understood or accurately measured. It is indeed often a matter of
considerable difficulty to discover any ill effects that may be due to
this cause, especially in the case of slow breeding animals, such as Man,
and the conclusions that have been arrived at with regard to the human
race have to a great extent been derived by analogy from observations
made upon lower animals. It would seem to be fairly generally agreed
that such ill effects as may exist arise for the most part from the
reinforcement or accentuation of hereditary weaknesses and defects that
is liable to occur in inbreeding and that members of a perfectly healthy
family might continue to mate with one another for several (perhaps for
many) generations without evil consequences, though possibly a loss of
vigour, strength or fertility might ultimately occur. In the case of the
Ptolemies of Egypt and the Incas of Peru inbreeding of this kind has (as
we have already observed in another connection) actually been practised
and does not seem to have produced any conspicuously bad results. There
is some evidence, too, that seems to point to the fact that the supposed
ill effects of inbreeding are due to the results of continuously similar
environment and conditions of life rather than to the physiological
resemblance of the parents, or at any rate that any evil effects of the
latter cause may be counterbalanced by a change of abode or of the mode of
living[251].
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account