The Psychology of ArithmeticThorndike, Edward L. (Edward Lee)
Science
The Psychology of Arithmetic
Thorndike, Edward L. (Edward Lee)
Arithmetic -- Study and teaching
A most interesting beginning at such an inventory of the actual uses
of arithmetic has been made by Wilson ['19] and Mitchell.[2] Although
their studies need to be much extended and checked by other methods of
inquiry, two main facts seem fairly certain.
First, the great majority of people in the great majority of their
doings use only very elementary arithmetical processes. In 1737 cases
of addition reported by Wilson, seven eighths were of five numbers or
less. Over half of the multipliers reported were one-figure numbers.
Over 95 per cent of the fractions operated with were included in this
list: 1/2 1/4 3/4 1/3 2/3 1/8 3/8 1/5 2/5 4/5. Three fourths of all
the cases reported were simple one-step computations with integers or
United States money.
Second, they often use these very elementary processes, not because
such are the quickest and most convenient, but because they have lost,
or maybe never had, mastery of the more advanced processes which would
do the work better. The 5 and 10 cent stores, the counter with
"Anything on this counter for 25¢," and the arrangements for payments
on the installment plan are familiar instances of human avoidance of
arithmetic. Wilson found very slight use of decimals; and Mitchell
found men computing with 49ths as common fractions when the use of
decimals would have been more efficient. If given 120 seconds to
do a test like that shown below, leading lawyers, physicians,
manufacturers, and business men and their wives will, according to my
experience, get only about half the work right. Many women, finding on
their meat bill "7-3/8 lb. roast beef $2.36," will spend time and
money to telephone the butcher asking how much roast beef was per
pound, because they have no sure power in dividing by a mixed number.
[2] The work of Mitchell has not been published, but the author has
had the privilege of examining it.
Test
Perform the operations indicated. Express all fractions in answers in
lowest terms.
_Add:_
3/4 + 1/6 + .25 4 yr. 6 mo.
1 yr. 2 mo.
6 yr. 9 mo.
3 yr. 6 mo.
4 yr. 5 mo.
-----------
_Subtract:_
8.6 - 6.05007 7/8 - 2/3 = 5-7/16 - 2-3/16 =
_Multiply:_
29 ft. 6 in. 7 × 8 × 4-1/2 =
8
------------
_Divide:_
4-1/2 ÷ 7 =
It seems probable that the school training in arithmetic of the past
has not given enough attention to perfecting the more elementary
abilities. And we shall later find further evidence of this. On the
other hand, the fact that people in general do not at present use a
process may not mean that they ought not to use it.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account