The Psychology of ArithmeticThorndike, Edward L. (Edward Lee)
Science
The Psychology of Arithmetic
Thorndike, Edward L. (Edward Lee)
Arithmetic -- Study and teaching
8 times the number of stripes in our flag is the number of years
from 1800 until Roosevelt was elected President. In what year was
he elected President?
From the Declaration of Independence to the World's Fair in Chicago
was 9 times as many years as there are stripes in the flag. How
many years was it?
(9) _Useless methods._--Bonds should not be formed between a described
situation and a method of treating the situation which would not be a
useful one to follow in the case of the real situation. For example, "If
I set 96 trees in rows, sixteen trees in a row, how many rows will I
have?" forms the habit of treating by division a problem that in reality
would be solved by counting the rows. So also "I wish to give 25 cents
to each of a group of boys and find that it will require $2.75. How many
boys are in the group?" forms the habit of answering a question by
division whose answer must already have been present to give the data of
the problem.
(10) _Problems whose answers would, in real life, be already
known._--The custom of giving problems in textbooks which could not
occur in reality because the answer has to be known to frame the problem
is a natural result of the lazy author's tendency to work out a problem
to fit a certain process and a certain answer. Such bogus problems are
very, very common. In a random sampling of a dozen pages of "General
Review" problems in one of the most widely used of recent textbooks, I
find that about 6 percent of the problems are of this sort. Among the
problems extemporized by teachers these bogus problems are probably
still more frequent. Such are:--
A clerk in an office addressed letters according to a given list.
After she had addressed 2500, 4/9 of the names on the list had not
been used; how many names were in the entire list?
The Canadian power canal at Sault Ste. Marie furnished 20,000
horse power. The canal on the Michigan side furnished 2-1/2
times as much. How many horse power does the latter furnish?
It may be asserted that the ideal of giving as described problems only
problems that might occur and demand the same sort of process for
solution with a real situation, is too exacting. If a problem is
comprehensible and serves to illustrate a principle or give useful
drill, that is enough, teachers may say. For really scientific teaching
it is not enough. Moreover, if problems are given merely as tests of
knowledge of a principle or as means to make some fact or principle
clear or emphatic, and are not expected to be of direct service in the
quantitative work of life, it is better to let the fact be known. For
example, "I am thinking of a number. Half of this number is twice six.
What is the number?" is better than "A man left his wife a certain sum
of money. Half of what he left her was twice as much as he left to his
son, who receives $6000. How much did he leave his wife?" The former is
better because it makes no false pretenses.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account