The Psychology of ArithmeticThorndike, Edward L. (Edward Lee)
Science
The Psychology of Arithmetic
Thorndike, Edward L. (Edward Lee)
Arithmetic -- Study and teaching
(12) _Ambiguities and falsities._--Consider the ambiguities and false
reasoning of these problems.
1. If you can earn 4 cents a day, how much can you earn in 6 weeks?
(Are Sundays counted? Should a child who earns 4 cents some day
expect to repeat the feat daily?)
2. How many lines must you make to draw ten triangles and five
squares? (I can do this with 8 lines, though the answer the book
requires is 50.)
3. A runner ran twice around an 1/8 mile track in two minutes. What
distance did he run in 2/3 of a minute? (I do not know, but I do
know that, save by chance, he did not run exactly 2/3 of 1/8 mile.)
4. John earned $4.35 in a week, and Henry earned $1.93. They put
their money together and bought a gun. What did it cost? (Maybe $5,
maybe $10. Did they pay for the whole of it? Did they use all their
earnings, or less, or more?)
5. Richard has 12 nickels in his purse. How much more than 50 cents
would you give him for them? (Would a wise child give 60 cents to a
boy who wanted to swap 12 nickels therefor, or would he suspect a
trick and hold on to his own coins?)
6. If a horse trots 10 miles in one hour how far will he travel in
9 hours?
7. If a girl can pick 3 quarts of berries in 1 hour how many quarts
can she pick in 3 hours?
(These last two, with a teacher insisting on the 90 and 9, might
well deprive a matter-of-fact boy of respect for arithmetic for
weeks thereafter.)
The economics and physics of the next four problems speak for
themselves.
8. I lost $15 by selling a horse for $85. What was the value of the
horse?
9. If floating ice has 7 times as much of it under the surface of
the water as above it, what part is above water? If an iceberg is
50 ft. above water, what is the entire height of the iceberg? How
high above water would an iceberg 300 ft. high have to be?
10. A man's salary is $1000 a year and his expenses $625. How many
years will elapse before he is worth $10,000 if he is worth $2500
at the present time?
11. Sound travels 1120 ft. a second. How long after a cannon is
fired in New York will the report be heard in Philadelphia, a
distance of 90 miles?
GUIDING PRINCIPLES
The reader may be wearied of these special details concerning bonds now
neglected that should be formed and useless or harmful bonds formed for
no valid reason. Any one of them by itself is perhaps a minor matter,
but when we have cured all our faults in this respect and found all the
possibilities for wiser selection of bonds, we shall have enormously
improved the teaching of arithmetic. The ideal is such choice of bonds
(and, as will be shown later, such arrangement of them) as will most
improve the functions in question at the least cost of time and effort.
The guiding principles may be kept in mind in the form of seven simple
but golden rules:--
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account