The Quarterly Journal of Science, Literature and the Arts, July-December, 1827Various
Science
The Quarterly Journal of Science, Literature and the Arts, July-December, 1827
Various
Arts -- Periodicals; Science -- Periodicals; Technology -- Periodicals
An inquiry into the manner a girl should sit may appear trifling
to those who have not been in the habit of seeing many cases of
distortion of the spine, but it is intimately connected with the
present subject, and is really of considerable importance. The
question has been disputed; one party insisting that girls should
always sit erect, while others are advocates for a lounging position.
It is not difficult to show that both are [p246] wrong;—when a
delicately formed girl is supposed to be sitting erect, she is
generally sitting crooked: to a superficial observer she may appear
quite straight; but any one who will sit on a music stool, and
endeavour to keep his body in a perpendicular line for ten minutes,
will be convinced that it is difficult for even a strong man to sit
as long as a delicate girl is expected to do, without allowing the
spine to sink to one side or to fall forwards.
The attempt to sit erect beyond a certain time is injurious, for
although bending the spine occasionally is useful rather than
hurtful, yet when it is done involuntarily, and when the bend is
attempted to be concealed by an endeavour to keep the head straight,
there is danger of the spine becoming twisted. Indeed, a double curve
is generally the consequence; there is first a bend to one side, to
give ease to the fatigued muscles; and then, to conceal this, there
is a second curve that is necessarily accompanied by a slight twist
in the vertical line of the whole column.
The proposal to allow children to sit in a crooked or lounging
position seems to have been founded on the idea that all the muscles
are more relaxed in this way than even when the child lies at full
length on its back. This notion is certainly incorrect, and such a
mode of sitting is injurious; for even were the muscles more relaxed
by it, the bones and ligaments acquire such a shape as necessarily
produces distortion.
It may naturally be asked how a girl should sit, since it would
appear, that whether she is in an erect or stooping posture, she is
equally in danger of becoming crooked. As sitting, in the manner
generally recommended, affords little or no support to one who is
weak, the safest answer would be, that a delicate girl should not sit
for even more than five or ten minutes without having some support
to her back, and when she is fatigued, that she should lie down or
recline on a couch. But as it would be very annoying to a girl not to
be allowed to sit up except for so short a time, and as a couch is
not always at hand, we must endeavour to show how a delicate girl may
remain in an upright posture, for a reasonable time without incurring
any risk of becoming crooked. This leads to an inquiry into the
merits of the chairs which are at present generally used by children.
[p247]
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account