The Quarterly Review, Volume 162, No. 324, April, 1886Various
History
The Quarterly Review, Volume 162, No. 324, April, 1886
Various
Periodicals
Thus it came to pass that about a century after the foundation of the
scriptorium, and when the library had grown to an imposing size, Abbot
Simon bestirred himself, and a new office was created in the Abbey, to
wit, that of Historiographer. In our time we should have given this
functionary a grander title, and called him Professor of History; but in
the 12th century, they called him what he was, a writer of history, and
from this time, in fact, the writing of history, after a certain
authorized method, began, and what had been called, and deserves to be
called, the St. Alban's School of History took its rise.
It is evident that before the 13th century had well begun, an historical
compendium of great value had already been drawn up, which must have
been compiled by careful students with a command of books such as during
this age was rare.
'The compilation,' says Dr. Luard, 'whenever and by
whomsoever it was written must be regarded as a very curious
and remarkable one. The very large number of sources
consulted, the miscellaneous character of many of the
extracts, the mixture of history and legend, the giving
fixed years to stories which even writers like Geoffrey of
Monmouth had left undated, the care at one time and the
carelessness at another, the slavishness with which one
authority is followed, and the recklessness with which
another is altered, the frequent confusion of dates, their
ignorance and want of care, the blunders displayed in many
instances from the compiler not understanding the author
whom he is copying, as is especially the case in the
extracts from the "Anglo-Saxon Chronicle;" all these
characteristics may well earn for the author the title that
Lappenberg has given to him, though under the name of
"Matthew of Westminster," namely, that of the "Verwirrer der
Geschichte." At the same time there is no doubt that he had
access to some materials which we no longer possess: and my
object has been to trace all his statements, where possible,
to their source, and to distinguish any additions that the
compiler has made when they are merely rhetorical
amplifications of his own, or when they are really from some
source not now extant.'--Pref. to vol. i., p. xxxiii.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account