The Railroad Question: A historical and practical treatise on railroads, and remedies for their abusesLarrabee, William
History
The Railroad Question: A historical and practical treatise on railroads, and remedies for their abuses
Larrabee, William
Railroads; Railroads -- United States; Railroads and state -- United States
Mr. Acworth is an Englishman who in former years wrote many bitter
things concerning the abuses which he then thought he saw in the
management of the railroads of his native country, which, according to
his own statement, are, besides those of the United States, the only
roads in the world for whose regulation competition has been relied upon
in the past. Mr. Acworth has become a convert to the _laissez faire_
theory of dealing with railroads and now evinces an unusual, but perhaps
pardonable, zeal in the defense of his new position. In the preface to
his book, "The Railways of England," he says upon the subject:
"I have published before now not a few criticisms (which
were meant to be scathing) on English railways anonymously.
I find myself using, under my own name, the language of
almost unvarying panegyric. This is partly to be explained
by the plan of the book, which professes to set before the
reader those points on each line which best merit
description--its excellencies, therefore, rather than its
defects. Much more, however, is it due to a change of
opinion in the writer.... I have found in so many cases that
a satisfactory reply existed to my former criticisms, that I
have perhaps assumed that such an answer would be
forthcoming in all; and if I have taken up too much the
position of an apologist, where I should have been content
to be merely an observer, let me plead as my excuse that I
am only displaying the traditional zeal of the new-made
convert."
Prof. Hadley, of whose work, "Railroad Transportation, its History and
its Law," mention has been made above, contributed an article to the
April, 1891, number of the _Forum_, under the title "Railway Passenger
Rates." He endeavors to show that the high passenger rates of American
railroads are due solely to superior service. He says:
"Continental Europe pays two-thirds as much as America or
England and gets an inferior article. India pays still less
and gets still less. The difference is seen both in quality
and quantity of service. In India express trains rarely run
at a greater speed than 25 miles an hour. In Germany and
France their speed ranges from 25 to 35 miles an hour, and
only in exceptional instances is more than 40 miles an hour.
In the United States and in England the maximum speed rises
as high as 50, or, in exceptional instances, 60 miles an
hour. With regard to the comfort of the cars in different
countries, there is more room for difference of opinion;
but there can be no doubt that the average traveler in the
United States, or even in the English third-class car, fares
better than he would in the corresponding class on
continental railroads, and infinitely better than the bulk
of travelers in British India."
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account