Beginning such a study of the causative factors of crime and taking
account of deviation from the normal among the criminalistic, we
immediately see that mental defect looms very large. Just how extensive
this factor is we are unable to say, because thoroughgoing examinations
of delinquents have not yet been registered in sufficient numbers.
Sutherland, who has had a large experience and has well considered the
matter, states in his work on Recidivism (p. 50) that it is not wide of
the mark to say that one-third of criminal recidivists are pathological
specimens, “suffering from physical and mental degeneracy characterized
by mental warp, instability and feeblemindedness,” and that of petty
offender recidivists it is equally safe to hold that two-thirds are
pathological in the same sense. The British Royal Commission for the
study of the feebleminded looked at 2,300 prisoners in cursory fashion
and without mental tests decided that they could determine about
ten per cent. to be feebleminded. Incomplete work from many sources
testifies to considerable proportions of feebleminded among criminals.
We ourselves, in our Chicago Institute, are for several reasons doing
fairly intensive work, and I would at once disclaim that our figures
have much statistical value. Yet of 620 cases of youthful repeaters
carefully studied by us and classified in a scale of mental ability
and peculiarity, twenty-six per cent. grade distinctly below the class
which we call poor in native ability.
We found:
Mentally subnormal--a class above the ordinary institutional 51
feebleminded types, but still well below the normal.
Dull from physical causes, including epilepsy. 36
Feebleminded of the upper or moron group. 48
Feebleminded of the imbecile group. 5
Psychoses (various types of mental disease). 22
---
162
Scattered for the most part through these classes we found 7-1/2 per
cent. of the total 620 to be definitely epileptic.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account