The time is ripe for better methods of handling this class of cases.
The study of recidivism shows it as a blot upon our civilization,
and demonstrates that many recidivists are mental defectives. The
study, on the other hand, of the individual defective criminal
demonstrates him to be a source of great financial loss and much
moral contagion. Studies in heredity prove that he frequently begets
his kind. Developments along medical and psychological lines have
given us practical methods for diagnosis of mental defectives--even
the border-line cases being easily determinable as such--and give us
assurance of the social future of this class of cases. The work of our
own institute proves not only the applicability of common-sense study
of causative factors in general to court work in this country, but
directly demonstrates the overwhelming value of early differentiation
of a type of offender, who by the very nature of his mental make-up is
bound under ordinary social conditions to become a recidivist.
In order to get a more business-like administration of criminal affairs
so that there may be practical application of at least some points
which are scientifically demonstrable as imperative for the well-being
of society, certain things are necessary. Concerning our immediate
point, the needs are: first, better education of everybody implicated
in the criminal situation as to the part that mental defect plays in
delinquency. Then in connection with criminal courts, and especially
in connection with juvenile courts, where the development of crime can
be checked, there should be thoroughgoing study of the recidivist. The
court should be acquainted with the practical value of such study and
should act on it. No offender should be allowed on parole unless he
is known to have the mental make-up which, on the whole, will in his
environment tend to prevent his freedom from being inimical to society.
Then, not a difficult matter to insure, there must be better classified
institutional treatment. Finally, the court should have the power to
adjudicate cases of mental defect in the best interests of society.
TREATMENT OF THE MENTAL DEFECTIVE WHO IS ALSO DELINQUENT
DR. HENRY H. GODDARD, VINELAND, NEW JERSEY
Twenty-five per cent. of delinquents are mentally defective. While we
have no absolute statistics, there are many indications that this is a
safe estimate. All mental defectives would be delinquents in the very
nature of the case, did not some one exercise some care over them.
There is only one possible answer to the question, “What is to be done
with the feebleminded person who is delinquent?” He must be cared for,
but he must be cared for in a place where we care for irresponsibles.
The jail or prison or reformatory, is not for him, neither must he be
turned loose on the streets or sent back to the home and environment in
which he has already become a delinquent.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account