The Rise and Fall of Prohibition: The Human Side of What the Eighteenth Amendment and the Volstead Act Have Done to the United StatesTowne, Charles Hanson
History
The Rise and Fall of Prohibition: The Human Side of What the Eighteenth Amendment and the Volstead Act Have Done to the United States
Towne, Charles Hanson
Prohibition -- United States; United States. Constitution. 18th Amendment
There are divorce laws upon our Statutes which millions of people
violently and bitterly oppose. Is a good Roman Catholic a bad American
citizen because his conscience refuses to let him condone the rulings
of our Courts in divorce trials?
On April 24, 1922, in St. Mary’s Protestant Episcopal Church, Emmerton,
Maryland, a sermon was preached by the Reverend W. A. Crawford-Frost on
the subject of “Obeying a Disreputable Law.”
The minister took as his text the verses from Esther 1:7 and 8: “And
they gave them drink in vessels of gold, (the vessels being diverse one
from another,) and royal wine in abundance, according to the state of
the king. And the drinking was according to the law; none did compel:
for so the king had appointed to all the officers of his house, that
they should do according to every man’s pleasure.”
He said in part:
“Recently President Harding and Secretary Hughes have made pathetic
appeals to the people of America to respect the law. That such
a request should have been considered necessary is itself a sad
commentary on the state of affairs existing in our republic. There
is a difference between obedience and respect. All good citizens
are called upon to obey the laws, whether they respect a particular
law or not; but they are not called upon to respect a law that is
not respectable.
“There are disreputable laws just as there are disreputable men.
“When is a man properly looked upon as disreputable? That depends
on the time and place and the people who do the looking, but in
most ages and countries there are some things that the universal
conscience of man holds to be not respectable. Thus lying, robbing,
cruelty and blasphemy are disreputable, and a man who lies, robs,
is cruel and blasphemes is a disreputable man.
“Accordingly, if a law can be shown to lie, to rob, to be cruel,
and to blaspheme God, it is a disreputable law and does not deserve
respect, though all good citizens should obey it until it is
repealed.
“To call upon the people of America to respect a law that is not
respectable is fundamentally dishonest, for it breaks down the
distinction between what is respectable and what is disreputable
and calls upon us to admire and look up to that which we should
despise and abhor.
“Now I will give you reasons why I consider that the Volstead
Act lies, robs, is cruel and blasphemes God. It may be that my
arguments are not sound, but they appear to me to be so, and all
that a man can do is to go according to his conscience and his
common sense.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account