Now, look at that track as established by our primitive wanderer and
see how lengthy and inconvenient it is, how ill fulfilling the object
of the traveller compared with what would have been established by
even a moderately intelligent and cursory survey of the ground as a
whole and the making of a plan. To begin with, it would have paid our
traveller to take a little more trouble in crossing the rather wider
gap in the marsh at L and the rather deeper ford at F, because he would
have gained very much in time and space with comparatively slight extra
effort had he surveyed the whole ground and thought things out. He was
only led on to the ford at D because it was suggested by the crossing
of the marsh at C. The first opportunity made the second. But to
continue the plan: F is nearly opposite the easier up gradients of the
hills, but, having surveyed that bad steep on the far side, he slightly
modifies his road, crossing the ridge at M behind a summit which hid
this way from the first traveller. Then he goes down the practicable,
though steep, slope at N, and so reaches B. The first road produced
haphazard by successive chances gives the lengthy and roundabout
trajectory A--C, D, H, K--B. The second, with very little extra labour,
gives him the far shorter and better trajectory A--L, F, M, N--B.
We see from this elementary example how the thinking out of the theory
of the Road is of advantage in practice. It may be urged that the
discovery of advantages as time goes on gradually improves the Road,
and in this way half-conscious development will always give you the
best road in the long run without studying its theory. But history is
against that view. Europe is full of roads thus established haphazard,
confirming themselves by use and by expenditure, and for centuries
neglecting opportunities which would have been present to the eye of
the most cursory and moderately intelligent survey.
This conflict of principle between _growth_ and _design_ in the
creation of the Road is at the root of half our modern crises in
road-making. The real issue is between those who would gradually add to
or develop from custom and those who would radically impose new plans,
and on a right decision the economic future of this country may well
depend.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account