The Singing Church: The Hymns It Wrote and SangLorenz, Edmund S. (Edmund Simon)
Religion
The Singing Church: The Hymns It Wrote and Sang
Lorenz, Edmund S. (Edmund Simon)
Hymns -- History and criticism
Medley’s hymn, “Oh, could I speak the matchless worth,” in not a
single phrase directly addresses the Deity. It is a purely subjective
expression of delight in the Lord Jesus Christ; and yet how
impressive, how delightful, how eminently worthy of the feelings of
any great congregation, is this hymn of Christian joy.
The hymn of emotion, therefore, supplies the soul’s demand, for it
satisfies the instinct for expression. It clarifies the intellectual
basis of the emotion and in so doing intensifies it. The collective
singing and mass expression of a common emotion intensify it still
further and fit it more fully to affect the will and the character,
and so give permanence to the influence of the truth underlying the
feeling. Where at the beginning the truth is but dimly perceived and
passively accepted, the resulting shallow feeling will be deepened. In
this way the hymn becomes a very generator of desirable religious
emotion.
_The Hymn of Inspiration._
It follows that the hymn may be a means of stimulating interest and
enthusiasm in connection with a topic or proposed course of action,
and may become the hymn of inspiration. Any line of thought or method
of presentation appealing to any emotion or impulse that creates
courage, hopefulness, confidence, assurance of success, will be
pertinent and desirable. The intenser element of direct exhortation
may be added, making a hortative hymn of one of mere inspiration.
_The Hymn of Personal Experience._
The hymn of personal experience differs from that of emotional
expression in being more subjective, more analytical of the effect
produced on the mind by the apprehension of the religious truth. The
latter is based on the realization of some objective truth or
doctrine, while the hymn of personal experience emphasizes the inner
experience in prayer, in specific exercise of faith, in a reaction of
the soul to some accomplished task, or to a season of communion with
God. The hymn of the blind poet, George Matheson, which has been so
widely used,
“O Love that wilt not let me go,
I rest my weary soul on Thee,”
is distinctly a hymn of Christian experience; while Isaac Watts gives
poignant expression to the emotions of the Christian, as he
contemplates the sufferings and death of Jesus Christ, borne to atone
for his sins,
“Alas! and did my Saviour bleed?
And did my Sovereign die?
Would he devote that sacred head
For sinners such as I!”
The hymn of personal experience has been rather heatedly objected to
by critics like Bishop Wordsworth. In some cases these “I and My”
hymns have been rewritten to meet the objection.
These critics who find their own “ego” offended by the apparent
emphasis of the hymn writer’s “ego” forget some rather important
factors in the situation.
1. It would have been rather presumptuous on the part of the writer to
speak for the collective “We” and “Us” who presumably were to sing his
verses.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account