The Southern Case for School SegregationKilpatrick, James Jackson
History
The Southern Case for School Segregation
Kilpatrick, James Jackson
African Americans -- Segregation; Segregation -- Southern States
The questions thus presented are not questions of constitutional
right but of legislative policy, which must be formulated,
not _in vacuo_ or with doctrinaire disregard of existing
conditions, but in realistic approach to the situations to which
it is to be applied.... The Federal courts would be going far
outside their constitutional function were they to attempt to
prescribe educational policies for the States in such matters,
however desirable such policies might be in the opinion of some
sociologists or educators. For the Federal courts to do so would
result, not only in interference with local affairs by an agency
of the Federal government, but also in the substitution of the
judicial for the legislative process in what is essentially a
legislative matter.
The public schools are facilities provided and paid for by the
States. The State’s regulation of the facilities which it furnishes
is not to be interfered with unless constitutional rights are
clearly infringed. There is nothing in the Constitution that
requires that a State grant to all members of the public a
common right to use every facility that it affords.... The equal
protection of the laws does not mean that the child must be treated
as the property of the State and the wishes of his family as to his
upbringing be disregarded.
In oral argument of the case, Thurgood Marshall had urged the
trial court to create judicial history by abandoning, on its own
motion, the precedents of many years in support of “separate but
equal.” Judges Parker and Timmerman were not willing to do so.
These unreversed decisions, they said, were squarely in point and
conclusive. If this long line of cases were to be overturned or held
outmoded, the Supreme Court itself would have to take that step. And
Parker concluded:
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account