The Southern Literary Messenger, Vol. I., No. 3, November, 1834Various
History
The Southern Literary Messenger, Vol. I., No. 3, November, 1834
Various
American literature -- 19th century -- Periodicals
at all, it is in consequence of his desertion of a field so wide and
magnificent, for the beaten and monotonous track of European character
and customs. Mr. Irving is undoubtedly most indebted for his literary
fame to such of his productions as are purely American; and it is
probable that in the future estimate which will be formed of his powers
and genius, his Bracebridge Hall, and the Tales of the Alhambra, will
hold no comparison in the scale of merit with his Knickerbocker, or
Salmagundi. But why amplify our illustrations? We will present no
absolute rule on the subject,--but rather choose to throw out these
opinions and suggestions to our readers and contributors, as matter for
their consideration.
In respect to the Legends of Fairy land,--which give such illimitable
scope to the fancy--and operate so feebly, if at all, in imparting
either rational amusement or instruction,--we confess that our opinions
are more decided and our objections more insurmountable. We think that
the day has past when such kind of reading will either be relished or
endured. In this age of comparative mental sobriety,--aliment like
that, is not likely to satisfy the intellectual appetite; no more than
the spectre tales of the last century would suit the rational and
regulated taste of the present time. This opinion it is not necessary
to enforce by a train of reasoning. We think that a large majority of
our readers will concur in the sentiment.
We are also informed from more than one quarter, that we awarded too
liberal and dangerous a compliment in our last number, to one article
especially, to wit--the "_Recollections of Chotank_;"--that we have
thereby, without intending it, given a sanction to vices which were
once fashionable, but now no longer so: that we have offended against
the laws of that chaste empress, TEMPERANCE,--who sits enthroned in so
many hearts, and who will not countenance the slightest inuendo against
her sovereignty; and that we have actually been guilty of the sin of
commending a paper, which contained enticing references to the social
excesses and abuses of ancient hospitality. To all this we reply, that
we spoke of the "_Recollections of Chotank_" as a _literary_
composition,--and that we had no more design, in the tribute which we
paid to its merit, to recommend the vices of "gambling and drinking,"
than we believe the author himself had, when he sat down to sketch his
reminiscences of by-gone days. We hope that the most fastidious will be
content with this disclaimer.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account