The Southern Literary Messenger, Vol. I., No. 3, November, 1834Various
History
The Southern Literary Messenger, Vol. I., No. 3, November, 1834
Various
American literature -- 19th century -- Periodicals
"Every one who has a soul for poetry has read the scripture sketches.
Hagar--Absalom--the sacrifice of Abraham--Zepthah's Daughter, are all
the productions of a rich imagination. They have their faults, we
allow, and so has another piece which he has called 'better moments,'
and so with many others; but we will take either and all of these, and
will plead the splendor of his genius before any tribunal of taste
under heaven. Willis's poems have passed through several editions. He
also pronounced a fine poem before Brown University. But the fame of
Willis, however proudly it may rest on his poetry, is still more widely
diffused by his prose.
"It was a cold morning in the winter of 1824-5, before sunrise, in a
division room of Yale College, that Willis gave the first sample of
that mellifluous prose which has since attracted such general
admiration. He was then commencing his sophomore year; and the student,
who had tried a freshman hand on the translations from the classics,
was now called to essay an original composition. We were class-mates,
but were not in the same division. It was not our good fortune,
therefore, to hear his first composition; but we never can forget the
merriment which it produced in college. If we mistake not, the theme of
his first essay was the dilemma of an old man who had lost his wife;
and was in sad perplexity about the plant which he ought to place at
the head of her grave. One suggested that an oak sapling was best; but
the old man contended that it would not in its infancy protect the
grave from the sun and rain; and when it grew up, it would produce no
good fruit, and would, moreover, with its spreading branches, _rot the
shingles of his house_. Plant after plant, and tree after tree, were
mentioned, the merits of which Willis scanned with great felicity of
thought and language. At last, after a due reflection on the useful and
the becoming, the old man resolved to plant a _cabbage_ on the grave of
his wife. The cold blooded critic, who delights to fasten his fangs on
rising merit, may pronounce the theme a very unfit subject for
merriment; but fellows of eighteen are no philosophers; and we doubt
whether any composition read within the walls of old Yale, ever
produced such a happy effect as the one we have just noticed.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account