The Southern Literary Messenger, Vol. II., No. 2, January, 1836Various
General
The Southern Literary Messenger, Vol. II., No. 2, January, 1836
Various
American literature -- 19th century -- Periodicals
One fytte is done--
Yet sith thus far we twain have gone,
I'll "ply my wrest,"[1] then tell thee more
Of the loves of the Lady Leonore.
L. L.
[Footnote 1: _Wrest_ was the name of the key used in tuning his harp
by the ancient _Songleur_ or minstrel. "Ply my wrest" is an expression
to be met with frequently in the early English poets.]
ENGLISH LANGUAGE IN AMERICA.
The preservation of a pure English diction is not sufficiently aimed
at in America. Some are so entirely Britannic, as to receive every
thing for legal tender in letters, which comes across the water. This
is thenceforward duly '_marqué au coin_.' Others are so patriotically
republican, as to set about the task of nursing the countless brood of
cis-Atlantic words, into literary respectability. Both are in error.
It is not enough to avoid Amercanisms; nor is it expedient to
manufacture a pye-bald dialect, of vulgarisms and provincialisms, for
the mere satisfaction of calling it our own. In England, no less than
here, the language is growing to an unhealthy exuberance, and many of
the words which {111} are fathered on the poor Americans, are
distempered excrescences of the overgrown British trunk. Nothing but
the appeal to a standard of former golden days of literature and
classic taste, can save the noble tongue of freemen from becoming an
unwieldy, cacophonious, inconsistent mass of crudities. How much more
is there danger, lest the other party, by encouraging unauthorized and
American inventions in language, lay the foundation for provincial
dialects, which shall hopelessly diverge from one another, until the
Mississippian and the Virginian shall be as diverse as were the
Athenian and the Macedonian. What this difference was, may be seen at
a glance even in Demosthenes on the crown; where the orator blunders
in Attic, while he reads in the same breath a decree of the Byzantes
in broad-mouthed Doric.
To some minds this may seem a trifling subject; like the countryman's
nightingale in Catullus, '_vox et praeterea nihil_.' But, as Mirabeau
said, _Words are things._ Language and thought act reciprocally. Unity
of speech presupposes unity of thinking; but it also propagates it.
Where provincial dialects begin to grow into languages, there is a
corresponding divergence of national feeling. In our boundless
country, after all our attempts to the contrary, this diversity of
language will take place. It is now taking place. We begin to
distinguish by his idiom and his pronunciation, the New Englander, the
Southron, and the native of the great Western Valley. And there is no
possibility of avoiding a separation of greater moment, without some
common and acknowledged standard to which the appeal may be made; a
standard not fabricated, but adopted--which shall be maintained by men
of letters, in opposition to the immensely varying license of the
illiterate mass in the respective districts of America.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account