The Southern Literary Messenger, Vol. II., No. 3, February, 1836Various
General
The Southern Literary Messenger, Vol. II., No. 3, February, 1836
Various
American literature -- 19th century -- Periodicals
Sweet Swallows of Salvation.'" There can be no doubt whatever of
D'Israeli's having pilfered this thing from Paul Ulric, for Mr.
Mattson having, inadvertently we suppose, written _Baskets_ for
_Biscuits_, the error is adopted by the plagiarist. But we have a
still more impudent piece of robbery to mention. The whole of the
_erudition_, and two-thirds of the words in the paragraph above,
beginning 'In the first place we are accused of vulgarity,' &c. is to
be found on page 42, vol. i, second edition, of The '_Curiosities!_'
Let us transcribe some of D'Israeli's words in illustration of our
remark. We refer the reader for more particular information to the
book itself.
"Horace censures the coarse humor of Plautus--Aristotle (whose
industry composed more than four hundred volumes) has not been less
spared by the critics. Diogenes Laertius, Cicero and Plutarch have
forgotten nothing that can tend to show his ignorance, his ambition,
and his vanity--Socrates, considered as the wisest, and most moral of
men, Cicero treated as an usurer, and the pedant Athenæus as
illiterate--Plato, who has been called, by Clement of Alexandria, the
Moses of Athens; the philosopher of the Christians by Arnobius, and
the god of philosophers by Cicero; Athenæus accuses of envy;
Theopompus of lying; Suidas of avarice; Aulus Gellius of robbery;
Porphyry of incontinence, and Aristophanes of impiety--Virgil is
destitute of invention, if we are to give credit to Pliny--Naucrates
points out the source (of the Iliad and Odyssey,) in the library at
Memphis, which, according to him, the blind bard completely
pillaged--Horace has been blamed for the free use he made of the minor
Greek {180} poets. Even the author of his (Virgil's) apology, has
confessed that he has stolen, from Homer, his greatest beauties, from
Apollonius Rhodius many of his pathetic passages, and from Nicander
hints for his Georgics."
Well, Mr. Mattson, what have you to say for yourself? Is not I.
D'Israeli the most impudent thief since the days of Prometheus?
In summing up an opinion of Paul Ulric, it is by no means our
intention to mince the matter at all. The book is despicable in every
respect. Such are the works which bring daily discredit upon our
national literature. We have no right to complain of being laughed at
abroad when so villainous a compound, as the thing we now hold in our
hand, of incongruous folly, plagiarism, immorality, inanity, and
bombast, can command at any moment both a puff and a publisher. To Mr.
Mattson himself we have only one word to say before throwing his book
into the fire. Dress it up, good sir, for the nursery, and call it the
"Life and Surprising Adventures of Dingy O'Dirty." Humph!--Only think
of Plato, Pliny, Aristotle, Aristophanes, Nicander, Aulus Gellius,
Naucrates, Athenæus, Theopompus and Apollonius Rhodius!!
MARTIN'S GAZETTEER.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account