The Southern Literary Messenger, Vol. II., No. 4, March, 1836Various
History
The Southern Literary Messenger, Vol. II., No. 4, March, 1836
Various
American literature -- 19th century -- Periodicals
"Because the speakers showed plainly by their looks and actions, that
their thoughts were running upon their own personal appearance, and
upon the figure they would cut before the ladies, when they should
arrive; and not upon the subject of the discourse. And furthermore,
their conversation was like that of {290} one talking in his
sleep--without order, sense, or connexion. The hearer always made the
speaker repeat in sentences and half sentences; often interrupting
him with 'what?' before he had proceeded three words in a remark; and
then laughed affectedly, as though he saw in the senseless unfinished
sentence, a most excellent joke. Then would come his reply, which
could not be forced into connexion with a word that he had heard; and
in the course of which he was treated with precisely the civility
which he had received. And yet they kept up the conversation with
lively interest as long as I listened to them."
"_The Mother and her Child_," we have seen before--but read it a
second time with zest. It is a laughable burlesque of the baby
'gibberish' so frequently made use of by mothers in speaking to their
children. This sketch evinces, like all the rest of the Georgia
scenes--a fine dramatic talent.
"_The Debating Society_" is the best thing in the book--and indeed
one among the best things of the kind we have ever read. It has all
the force and freedom of some similar articles in the Diary of a
Physician--without the evident straining for effect which so
disfigures that otherwise admirable series. We will need no apology
for copying _The Debating Society_ entire.
About three and twenty years ago, at the celebrated school in
W------n, was formed a Debating Society, composed of young gentlemen
between the ages of seventeen and twenty-two. Of the number were two,
who, rather from an uncommon volubility, than from any superior gifts
or acquirements, which they possessed over their associates, were by
common consent, placed at the head of the fraternity.--At least this
was true of one of them: the other certainly had higher claims to his
distinction. He was a man of the highest order of intellect, who,
though he has since been known throughout the Union, as one of the
ablest speakers in the country, seems to me to have added but little
to his powers in debate, since he passed his twenty-second year. The
name of the first, was Longworth; and McDermot was the name of the
last. They were congenial spirits, warm friends, and classmates, at
the time of which I am speaking.
It was a rule of the Society, that every member should speak upon the
subjects chosen for discussion, or pay a fine; and as all the members
valued the little stock of change, with which they were furnished,
more than they did their reputation for oratory, not a fine had been
imposed for a breach of this rule, from the organization of the
society to this time.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account